※ [本文转录自 historia 看板] 作者: MRZ (LQY) 看板: historia 标题: 军事史之史观理论013 时间: Wed Mar 2 11:16:19 2005 The 20th century has seen the publishing of hecatombs of good narrative history-writing on war and warfare after ‘The Golden Age’ but rather few works which can match the best of that period in terms of originality or scholarship. Among those few, four stand out as particularly imaginative and innovative: D.S. Freeman's Lee's Lieutenants (1942–1944), John Keegan’s The Face of Battle (1976), and Martin van Creveld's Supplying War (1977) and Command in War (1985). Common to these works is a comparatively novel approach to some of the recurrent motifs in the writings on past warfare, and also an uncommonly graphic and thought-evoking way of describing the realities of war, particularly the horrors and the unbelievable bravery (Freeman and Keegan), and the incredible malfunctions and acts of folly (van Creveld). 即使在‘黄金时代’之後﹐二十世纪仍旧出现了许许多多优秀的战史着作﹐但仅有 少数几本能够比得上这些前辈。其中又只有四本书可谓黄金时代以後的最佳着作﹕ DS费理曼的‘李将军的副官们(1942-1944)’﹔约翰齐根的‘战役面貌(1976)’﹔马 丁范克雷瓦德的‘补给战(1977)’与‘战争指挥(1985)’。这些着作都以近似小说 的笔法﹐来诠述与描写战史﹐并以另类的观点来形容战场的境况﹐从而激发出读者 的想像力﹐得以让人更能深入的了解战争的本质。比如说费理曼和齐根就擅长描写 战场的恐怖与当事人不可思议的勇气表现﹐而范克雷瓦德则擅长描述当事人面对危 机时﹐一定会出现的无能与愚蠢的反应。 -- LQY评注﹕这四本书不买可惜﹐但台湾不进口翻译﹐更可惜﹗ -- 万物皆非主，唯曼尼大神，至圣之先知，亚当史密斯。 La ilaha ill money，Adam Smith rasula'Llah 荣耀归於曼尼。自宇宙之初成﹐贯古今与未来﹐直至永恒不灭。喀锵！（收银机响声） Gloria patri Money. Sicut erat in principio, et nunc, et semper, et in saecula saeculorum.Ka-ching! --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 61.30.77.184 --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 140.112.250.145