作者ahiru (地狱野鸭)
看板VISA
标题Re: [北美] 澄清申请H-1B十月不下来的争议
时间Mon Aug 23 23:02:41 2010
首先感谢你找了这麽多资料
但是,你的解读在我看来并不正确
因为根本没有甚麽旧制跟新制
一切是应该照着C大找的这个资料跟CFR为准
当然,我也对我之前推文发生的错误致以最高的歉意~^_^|||
你会觉得有旧制跟新制是因为你一直执着於Q&A里的一句话
"Once a timely filing has been made, the automatic cap-gap extension will
begin and will continue until the H-1B petition adjudication process has been
completed."
当你在问C大要怎麽解释这句时
你根本性的忽略一个前提
这个制度是设计给大多数H-1B申请的学生
其OPT+grace period的时间都到不了10/1的情形
(其实通常状况是,OPT结束时间跟H-1B的开始日都会有数月的差距)
所以C大找的规定、你找的这个答案跟你找的上个答案都一直围绕着10/1(9/30)打转
那是因为这个设计本来就是给H-1B批准在10/1号之前(虽然开始日是10/1)
但因为OPT已经过期而无法工作的F-1申请者
(也有人是连grace period都没有到10/1故根本无法待在美国)
所以你上面回文的资料里
在我举出来的这句话後面他就分成H-1B准批及拒绝两种情形
在已准批的状况里,他就直接讲说申请者可以工作到9/30
那是因为这几个问题都已经先预定10/1就是H-1B的开始日
(也就是H-1B一般会在10/1号前批准)
那如果H-1B的开始日不是10/1
那就应该是要等准批之後才能继续工作才比较合理
(也就是10/1到许可日之间不能工作)
因为这本来就是H-1B的基本原则
对原本没有工作许可的人,本来就是要等到H-1B批准後才能工作
为甚麽OPT就可以例外?那是因为我讲的这种状况的人太多
所以才会有Cap-Gap的制度,但例外并不是无穷止境的
您是这个版上热心解答问题的版众之一
且您的答案也常常会当成参考资料
如果你有这样的认知
我是觉得你在解答问题时应该要更小心
如果因为你的一句话让提问者误判情势的话
那请问他是要找谁负责?
共勉之~^^
※ 引述《hangsh (stoney)》之铭言:
: 主旨如题,对於有关争议疑问的部份再作说明:
: 资料来源网站: USCIS官方网站
: http://tinyurl.com/5dd9ox
: What were the prior cap-gap regulations for F-1 students?
: The prior regulations addressed the cap-gap problem by authorizing an
: extension of an F-1 student’s authorized stay, but they did not extend the
: student’s employment authorization. This extension was not automatic; a
: notice had to be published in the Federal Register announcing the extension.
: Under the prior regulations, when this Federal Register notice was published,
: the student’s authorized stay was extended, but not the employment
: authorization. This meant the student could remain in the United States until
: October 1, when the approved H-1B employment began, but could not work until
: then.
: If a Federal Register notice authorizing an extension was not published,
: affected students would in many cases be required to leave the United States,
: apply for an H-1B visa, and seek readmission to the United States in H-1B
: status.
: How is the cap-gap situation changed under the interim final rule?
: F-1 academic students on post-completion OPT maintain valid F-1 status until
: the expiration of their OPT. Once that OPT has ended, they are authorized to
: remain in the United States for up to 60 days to prepare for departure.
: Under this rule, the F-1 status of students is automatically extended when
: the student is the beneficiary of an H-1B petition for the next fiscal year
: (with an October 1 employment start date) filed on his or her behalf during
: the period in which H-1B petitions are accepted for that fiscal year.
: The automatic extension terminates when USCIS rejects, denies, or revokes the
: H-1B petition.
: If the H-1B petition filed on behalf of the student is selected, the student
: may remain in the United States and, if on post-completion OPT, continue
: working until the October 1 start date indicated on the approved H-1B
: petition.
: The student may benefit from this provision only if he or she has not
: violated his or her status.
: 将旧制与修正後作个比较,答案就出来了
: 以上资料updated:04/10/2008
: 没有必要去研判什麽保守不保守,抵触法条等,你我都不是制定相关法规的人员
--
我是野鸭大叔~~(  ̄ c ̄)y▂ξ
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 67.87.233.104
1F:→ hangsh:首先谢谢您的指教! 08/24 01:09
2F:→ hangsh:问题的重点是原PO已申请H-1B(PENDING中)OPT已过期,假设9月 08/24 01:10
3F:→ hangsh:30日後,H-1B仍没有审批结果,10月1日起是否可以工作? 08/24 01:11
4F:→ hangsh:我的认知是可以--根据USCIS,您认为不可以/根据CFR 08/24 01:11
5F:→ hangsh:至於正确答案,有待证实,不是你我各说各话。 08/24 01:12
6F:→ hangsh:最後奉劝法律人在没有正确答案前没资格说误判情势,要谁负责 08/24 07:12
7F:→ hangsh:等语,PTT只是供大家讨论谘询分享经验的论坛~~ 08/24 07:16
8F:→ camouflage:回答问题还是慎重一点好 不然宁可让当事人自己找答案 08/24 22:09