作者goodafternoo ()
站内Statistics
标题[问题] 如果比例的95% CI.上界超过1可以吗?
时间Thu Jan 22 11:17:45 2009
想请问一下
如果在算 p_hat 的95% C.I.时
得到的 p_hat=0.8235 及 95% C.I.=(0.642,1.005)
95% C.I.的公式为 p_hat +or- 1.96*sqrt[ p_hat*(1-p_hat)/n ]
上界的部份超过1
一般会直接照公式就将此组C.I.写上?
还是会将上界用p的最大上界1 代入呢?
谢谢!!
1F:→ bmka:Replace it with 1; or use exact method to obatin CIs. 01/22 11:26
2F:→ goodafternoo:若是以1取代的话 在哪本书或哪篇paper内有提到呢? 01/22 11:30
3F:→ goodafternoo:因为我印象中有看过取代1的这种方式 不过一直找不到 01/22 11:31
4F:→ goodafternoo:在哪里看到的.. 因为要证明给别人看用1取代.. 01/22 11:31
5F:→ goodafternoo:所以希望能有本书或文章可以证明..谢谢!! 01/22 11:32
6F:→ bmka:Do you know how to interpret CI??? 01/22 11:32
7F:→ goodafternoo:100次有95次那个p_hat包含在此区间内 <-这样对吗? 01/22 11:33
8F:→ goodafternoo:哈.. 是此区间包含p_hat... 01/22 11:33
9F:→ bmka:The problem is that the use of asymptotic variance 01/22 11:34
10F:→ bmka:to construct CIs may not yield good coverage probability. 01/22 11:35
11F:→ bmka:espically when \hat p is close to 0 or 1. 01/22 11:36
12F:→ bmka:That's why I recommend using exact CIs instead. 01/22 11:37
13F:→ bmka:Hey, your interpretation of CI is completely wrong. 01/22 11:38
14F:→ goodafternoo:那可以请教一下exact CI要怎麽求得吗? 01/22 11:38
15F:→ bmka:use binomial distribution 01/22 11:39
※ 编辑: goodafternoo 来自: 140.128.153.200 (01/22 11:48)
16F:→ bmka:oops, 11楼 should be p instead of \hat p 01/22 12:04