作者riddlerkuo (飞騨古川や～♪)
看板StarWars
标题Re: [问题] EP3三个问题请教(杜库/安纳金/帕米)
时间Wed Jan 4 16:19:07 2017
: 推 riddlerkuo: (1)的问题很简单，记得以前看过讨论； 01/04 02:47
: → riddlerkuo: Dooku知道帕斐汀就是西帝。临死前的表情是1.他和西帝 01/04 02:48
: → riddlerkuo: 原本的计划是拉安纳金入黑暗面，但他想不到自己变成 01/04 02:48
: → riddlerkuo: 祭品 2. 想不到西帝真的做得那麽绝 01/04 02:49
: → riddlerkuo: 至於就算当时Dooku掀帕斐汀的底，议长他也可以用这是 01/04 02:49
: → riddlerkuo: Sith胡说八道混过去。在那个时间点，Dooku自己也明白 01/04 02:50
: → riddlerkuo: 讲什麽也没用，所以只剩下那个表情，什麽也讲不出来。 01/04 02:50
: → riddlerkuo: (1)问题很简单，从电影版里交待有关西斯的脉络中就能 01/04 02:51
: → riddlerkuo: 合理化Dooku最後的表情。 01/04 02:51
: → riddlerkuo: 退万步说，电影小说已经很清楚交待，Dooku知道西帝的 01/04 02:52
: → riddlerkuo: 身份。上面推文提到的，也是基於小说文字的描述。 01/04 02:52
: → riddlerkuo: Dooku出言抗议没用，Palpatine当下都能凹过去， 01/04 02:53
: → riddlerkuo: 一切都是西斯的谎言，安纳金快杀了他。结案。 01/04 02:54
: → riddlerkuo: 要看解释这里也有 https://goo.gl/VbikFX 01/04 02:55
: → riddlerkuo: 外国网友也是引电影小说的部份来说明 01/04 02:55
: → riddlerkuo: 第一篇回答就很清楚了。 01/04 02:56
: → BITMajo: Sith的本质是背叛，但Sidious和Dooku如果本来就计画好 01/04 11:56
: → BITMajo: 要拉Anakin进黑暗面的话，如果Dooku清楚一师一徒制的话 01/04 11:56
: → BITMajo: 那Dooku既同意帮Sidious拉拢Anakin，又相信Sidious会留 01/04 11:57
: → BITMajo: 住他的性命，怎麽想都有点奇怪 01/04 11:58
: → BF109Pilot: 没错Darth Majius 以杜库的立场 会变这样下场实在很怪 01/04 12:08
就真的是Dooku蠢啊www
上面推文提到的讨论
https://goo.gl/VbikFX
The reason Dooku didn't reveal that when Skywalker fought him
because
Sidious promised that he would survive (duh!). The high-level plan
(told to him by Sidious) would be that he, Dooku, would be "captured"
by Skywalker, and then would "discover" the true extent of Confederacy's
crimes... and be cleanly separated from it when Palpatine crushes CIS.
引小说:
"It will be," he said slowly, meditatively, as though he spoke only
to himself, "an embarrassment to be captured by him."
[discussing Anakin]...
"It is... fatiguing, to play the villain for so long, Master. I find
myself looking forward to an honorable captivity." (src: same ROTS
novelization... this statement was followed by exposition of what
the post-capture plans were).
http://i.imgur.com/EUNr0uI.jpg 小说内页截图
Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith
平装本p.51~52
Del Rey/April 2, 2006 ISBN: 0345428846
--
Space... the Final Frontier.
These are the voyages of the starship Enterprise.
Its continuing mission: to explore strange new worlds,
to seek out new life and new civilizations,
to boldly go where no one has gone before.
Picard: "Warp 9, Engage!!!"
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc), 来自: 218.173.75.161
※ 文章网址: https://webptt.com/cn.aspx?n=bbs/StarWars/M.1483517950.A.2ED.html
※ 编辑: riddlerkuo (218.173.75.161), 01/04/2017 16:19:58
1F：推 BITMajo: 看小说的原文，我会认为Dooku和普通的西斯价值观不太一样 01/04 17:20
2F：→ BITMajo: 至於到底是怎样，反正都是脑补...先不说小说跟电影是两个 01/04 17:21
3F：→ BITMajo: 作品，就算小说给了完整解释也弥补不了电影剧情没说明好 01/04 17:21
4F：→ BITMajo: 的事实... 01/04 17:21
5F：→ riddlerkuo: 官方小说脑补?! (笑) 01/05 01:27
6F：推 BITMajo: 不是说官方小说脑补，而是小说内文也没清楚交代完整情况 01/05 02:19
7F：→ BITMajo: 而网友根据小说内文推出的论点就会有推测的成分 01/05 02:19