作者owenkuo (Chewie, we're home)
看板StarWars
标题Re: [闲聊] 路克在第六集ㄧ开始
时间Mon Aug 17 21:46:41 2015
※ 引述《hilikus (呼呼)》之铭言:
: 最近在复习456集,才发现路克在闯入贾霸宫殿时对猪头兵用锁喉功,
Gamorrean
http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Gamorrean
: 那应该是Dark side的招式啊!(记得以前玩电动是这样…)希望没OP!
先不论Luke就算用上黑暗面的招式也不是什麽太意外的事;
电影那段,网路上查得到的剧本是这样写的;
Luke
raises his hand and points at the puzzled guards,
who immediately
lower their spears and fall back.
The young Jedi lowers his hand and moves on down the hallway.
http://www.scifiscripts.com/scripts/revengeofthejedi.txt
从描述来看,这应该还算是心灵控制(Mind tricks)的范围。
(心灵控制也分很多层次,
从短时间幻像到洗脑或制造对手的恐惧,都是心灵控制在延长线上的技巧)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
另外这个页面
http://goo.gl/w9DfPb ,也有人问到这个问题。
撇开几段讨论光明面黑暗面的分类定义或哲学观逻辑等等......
有人认为Luke那是原力锁喉(force choke) 像第一个留言者说的;
但也有人不这麽认为。譬如;
Daniel Camarillo认为:
I don't believe he did force choke them. The Gesture he used
didn't
look like a "Squeeze" to me,
more like a relaxed point. Furthermore,
the mannerisms of the affected guards doesn't jive with someone who
was force choked. there was no gasping, no heavy breathing, and at
the end,
the guards simply retreated to the walls they were leaning on.
Kyle Keel认为:
Luke didn't force choke the Gamoreans, he used a dark grey technique
that
caused fear in the guards without doing any actual harm.
从这几个角度看,Luke当时用的"技巧",应该还只是心灵控制,还不是锁喉。
至於算是光明面还是黑暗面,那又是另外的问题:p
--
Beware the Court of Owls, that watches all the time,
Ruling Gotham from a shadowed perch, behind granite and lime.
They watch you at your hearth, they watch you in your bed.
Speak not a whispered word about them,
or they'll send the Talon for your head.
Court of Owls
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc), 来自: 36.237.252.9
※ 文章网址: https://webptt.com/cn.aspx?n=bbs/StarWars/M.1439819209.A.7E1.html
※ 编辑: owenkuo (36.237.252.9), 08/17/2015 22:00:51
1F:推 rapnose: 推这篇解释。 08/18 09:33
2F:推 Luciferspear: 小时候看到路克後面爆怒狂劈以为他输定了 08/18 10:49
3F:→ Luciferspear: 结果竟然砍赢了 超傻眼 该说好险卢卡斯不是华人? 08/18 10:49
4F:推 BF109Pilot: 路克是看到老爸断手悬崖勒马 不然他可能也会步上後尘 08/18 11:18
5F:→ BF109Pilot: 变成Darth Lukius之类的称号 08/18 11:19
6F:→ owenkuo: Vader: 醒醒吧,你没有妹妹! Luke: NOOOOOOOOOOOOO!! 08/18 11:28
7F:→ BF109Pilot: 其实在EP3上映前 我一直以为莉亚是姊姊 08/18 11:35
8F:推 e12401421: 就是一种乱拳打死老师傅的概念 08/19 23:42
9F:推 xenojack: 从最近新出TRPG的设定来看原力闪电跟锁喉都是吃黑暗原力 08/26 20:41
10F:→ xenojack: 点,累积一定数量的黑暗原力才会进堕落事件检定,所以 08/26 20:41
11F:→ xenojack: 必要时候电一下锁一下也是很合理的(笑) 08/26 20:41