Mailbag: Is Sandoval the real deal? 邮包：Sandoval这孩子是真货吗？ Looks like Pablo Sandoval might be the real deal. If he can handl positions he plays, I think they may have found a steal as a non-drafted free agent. I haven't seen a player that can hit like him since Will Clark. He so far has shown that he can handle Minor League and Major League pitching, and I believe he will be a yearly .300 hitter. What's your thought? -- Chuck A., Ventura, Calif. 看起来Sandoval像是个真货！如果他能把他守的每个位置都上手，我想他将会是 未选秀签约球员中的一偷。自从Will Clark後，我还没见过谁的打击跟这家伙一 样。如今他已证明了他能掌握小联盟与大联盟的投球，而我相信这孩子会成为平 均三成的打者。你觉得呢？ -- Chuck A., Ventura, Calif My thought is that Sandoval is an intriguing player, to say the v His ability to catch and play the infield corners makes him extremely handy. At bat, it seems like there's no pitch he can't hit. That said, his Major League career is all of 21 games old, entering the Arizona series. Let's see how he handles his first slump, and let's see how diligently he prepares himself for Spring Training. After Sandoval drove in five runs on Sunday, we learned that he became the first Giants rookie to achieve that feat since ... Damon Minor. So don't let Sandoval's fast start seduce you. As with others, he must withstand the test of time. 对我而言，最低限度 Sandoval 也会是个吸引人的好球员。他能接捕，他能在内 野角落讨生活，这让他非常非常好用。在打击上，似乎还没有球是他打不到的！ 目前他的大联盟生涯就是这21场，进入亚利桑那的系列战後，让我们瞧瞧他怎麽 处理他的首次低潮，让我们瞧瞧他如何在春训时充分准备。礼拜天，Sandoval单 场打下 5分打点，他是在某人之後，第一个达到这个高度的菜鸟——笑面虎.... Damon Minor 囧！所以别急着让 Sandoval 的快速起飞迷惑了你，如同其他人， 他必须挺过时间的考验。 -- Remember when Albert Pujols first came up? The Cardinals had him little bit of everything (first base, third base, left field) and he eventually settled in at first. Because of his bat, they had to find a place for him. I say all of this because Sandoval reminds me of Pujols' situation. We are going to have to find a place for him because he can flat-out hit. What do you think the Giants are planning to do with Pablo? -- James J., Birmingham, Ala. 还记得扑吼狮当年被叫上来的光景吗？红雀队让他什麽都来一点：一垒、三垒、 左外野，而他最後安顿在一垒垒包上。他们得找个位置给他那杰出的打击能力。 我说这些是因为── Sandoval 让我想起了扑吼狮的状况。我们必须替他和他 高效的打击找出空间。你认为 Giants 打算怎麽处理呢？ -- James J., Birmingham, Ala. With Bengie Molina signed for 2009 and Buster Posey ascending rap Sandoval's unlikely to wind up behind the plate. Since that obviously leaves first and third base, I'd imagine he'll land in the spot that's not taken by a big acquisition or a teammate (if Conor Gillaspie proves he's ready for third base or Travis Ishikawa or John Bowker takes command at first). 我们有摸你那的合约，到2009；我们有大物新人 Buster Posey 的迅速成长， Sandoval 似乎不会死死缠在本垒板後面。除了常见的一三垒外，我想他甚至 可能降落在任何一个没有FA大物、没有其他队友卡位的位置。(如果二轮新秀 Conor Gillaspie 证明他能接手三垒，而石川或 John Bowker 顺利吃下一垒 的话)。 (...无敌工具人？) -- Sandoval can play. Posey is another Bob Horner or Barry Bonds, meaning he needs little or no time in the Minors. When you sign players that no other general manager wishes to touch during a rebuilding year, you get no knockout offers before the waiver deadline. Molina to the Yankees instead of Pudge Rodriguez was a no-brainer. Brian Sabean did not make it happen. Why on earth does Molina need to be with this team, as it's assembled? He is a warrior and deserved to be with a winner. Why do the Giants not hold Sabean to a higher standard? Do you dare put this question in your mailbag and mention the Dave Roberts contract or the Joe Nathan trade? -- John B., St. James City, Fla. Sandoval 能打球，而 Posey，是下一个Bob Horner or Barry Bonds(?!)，他 不会花太多时间蹲小联盟。当你签了一个任何GM在重建期都不会想碰的球员， 而在交易截止前居然没有出击！摸你那去洋基！而不该是小胖 I-ROD去洋基！ 如此不用大脑思考的事情，Brian Sabean居然没想到！为什麽摸你那必须待在 这个球队？当蒐集品吗？他是个战士，他值得成为赢家 (...心酸)。巨人军为 什麽不用高一点的标准检视 Sabean？你敢把这个问题放在 mailbag 上顺道提 及 Dave Roberts的烂合约或 Joe Nathan那笔交易吗？！(...心酸 again) -- John B., St. James City, Fla. I don't need to mention the Roberts contract or the Nathan trade -- you just did. Certainly, Sabean has made his share of regrettable deals. But look at what Detroit got in exchange for Rodriguez: right-handed reliever Kyle Farnsworth. This indicates that the Yankees didn't have much to offer for Molina, who the Giants need if they're going to sustain any sort of resurgence next season. It's a little early to throw Sandoval or Posey into an everyday Major League catching role. 你已经提及Dave Roberts的烂合约或 Joe Nathan那笔交易了，的确，Sabean 该为他那几笔心碎交易感到惭愧。但是看看洋基丢出了什麽换小胖吧！ Kyle 放肆火！这不说明了洋基也没什麽可以拿来交易摸你那──这个巨人下季若 想或多或少的复苏的重心。另一方面，现在把 Sandoval or Posey丢上来每 天接捕，似乎也有些操之过急。 -- What are the chances of Randy Winn still being a Giant next season? He is hitting brilliantly at the moment. But he also is on a relatively large salary ($8.25 million next year), and with Aaron Rowand, Roberts, Fred Lewis and Winn on the roster, there clearly is an odd man out. Roberts would be the ideal man to move, but he is injury-prone and expensive, as opposed to Winn, who is expensive but is currently doing wonders to help his trade value. The Rays may be willing to welcome him back to use his experience, professionalism and quality, and should be in a financial position to pay him. What are your thoughts? -- Ian W., San Francisco Randy Winn 明年还有可能当巨人吗？他打击不赖，不过也吃了一大堆薪资 (一年8.25M)，而且我们有 Rowand, Roberts, Lewis, 再加一个 Winn，似 乎有点多余了。Roberts 应该是出清的理想人选，但他又伤又贵 。相对来 说 Winn 虽贵，而工作绩效优良，有拍卖价值 。光芒可能会想要他回去贡 献经验、敬业精神，以及他的才能。而且他们出得起钱。你说呢？ -- Ian W., San Francisco I'd guess that Winn is more likely to remain with the Giants than to depart. I agree that his trade value never will be higher, so I'm sure that the Giants will listen to offers for him. By the way, in citing the personnel logjam, you forgot Nate Schierholtz, who could be the biggest factor in prompting the Giants to move an outfielder. Winn can block deals to 10 clubs, so that might make him somewhat difficult to deal. Also, teams want power-hitting outfielders -- there's not as much demand for competent high-average hitters like Winn, believe it or not. And Lewis' foot problems could force the Giants to keep their outfield well-stocked to protect themselves. 比起离开，我猜 Winn会更想留在巨人。 他的交易价值可能真的到顶了，我 确定巨人会好好听取对他的报价。还有，在你那堆举例里，你忘了一个名字： Nate Schierholtz。他可能是巨人去动外野手的重要因素 。 Winn可以提出 对 10支球队的交易否决， 这也让他的比较难处理掉。还有一点，比起Winn 这样的高打率打者，球队更爱巨炮外野手 (最好是....)，信不信由你！最後， 基於 Lewis的脚伤，巨人可能会继续囤积大量外野手。 -- I know it is wrong to ever root for the Dodgers, but is it OK to secretly want them to beat Arizona so Brandon Webb won't get a bonus in the Cy Young Award voting? -- Kawamoto C., San Jose, Calif. 我知道我们应该痛恨躲人一生一世但是偷偷希望他们打爆小蛇队布兰登韦伯 让林盲肠多拿点 CYA的票好像又还OK怎麽办?!?!?! -- Kawamoto C., San Jose, Calif. I donned layers of orange-and-black clothing, squatted at the site where home plate used to be at Candlestick Park, arranged photographs of the Giants' Hall of Famers around orange-and-black candles, smeared on some of Will Clark's unused eye black, chanted Brian Johnson's name as if it were a mantra, played cassette tapes of Giants highlights from the Russ Hodges-Lon Simmons era and waited for a sign. The answer came: Yes. 想当年我穿着橘黑色衣服蹲在烛台球场帮那些Hall of Famers拍照.... (以下删去 5 行倚老卖老的回忆) 答案是：Yes. -- Will Bowker get a chance to reclaim the first-base job in September? I, for one, was actually shocked the Giants would play yo-yo with him. I don't want to see him turn into another Damon Minor, Lance Niekro, or Todd Linden. On a power-starved team, you can't keep messing with the power prospects. -- Christopher C., Benecia, Calif. 九月里 Bowker是否还有机会被叫上来当一垒手？我个人对巨人把他当溜溜球 实在有点震惊。我不想看见他变成另一个笑面虎 Minor、蝴蝶球王子 Niekro、 ５项全能４Ａ球员 Linden。在一个渴望长打力的球队，你不能继续这样摧残 自己的 power prospects呀。 -- Christopher C., Benecia, Calif. Given that Ishikawa, Scott McClain and Sandoval seem to be rotating at first base, Bowker's best shot appears to be 2009 Spring Training. I agree that potential power hitters should be nurtured, not neglected. But if the Giants decide that Ishikawa or Sandoval has more pop (at 36, McClain's long-term value appears limited), cracking the lineup will be difficult for Bowker. 看来石川、老人 McClain、Sandoval 已经接掌一垒的位置了， Bowker最好的 切入点在０９年春训。我同意有炮瓦的作物要好好养，莫乱来；不过如果巨人 觉得石川或 Sandoval更有爱 (老将 McClain价值有限)，那闯进先发名单对 Bowker 而言就有难度了。 -- As a theoretical exercise, what sort of return could we get if Tim Lincecum was available on the trade market, and do you think the Giants would ever consider this option? -- David S., Sydney, Australia 纯就理论而言，把林盲肠放到交易市场会得到怎麽样的回报？ 你想巨人会考虑这样的可能性吗？ -- David S., Sydney, Australia At least three top prospects, or a proven non-arbitration-eligible hitter (good luck finding one of those) along with a decent pitcher or two. At least. As a theoretical exercise, I wonder how many orderlies from the closest mental hospital would be required to round up the Giants' front-office officials if they dealt Lincecum. That's a long-winded way of saying that I doubt the Giants will consider this option. 至少三名顶级新秀，或一名不具仲裁资格，已证明的好打者，( 如果找得到那 还真好运) 外加一两个不错的投手。纯就理论而言，此举若成真，不知附近的 精神病院需要新聘多少看护。总之，巨人真会做出这一步选择？我严重怀疑。 -- 这次的 mailbag讨论主题是Sandoval！ 很期待这个能捕又能打的新秀，但前有摸你那卡位，後有大物波西虎视眈眈， 现在高层好像有意让他多练几个位置，增加上场空间； 一如当年一三游外野捕手都来一点的菲力。 我觉得有点可惜，毕竟有棒子的好捕手难找， 现在摸你那没狠下心交易出去，球团还希望靠他一年多赢几场， Sandoval似乎就是打游击战了。 大家看法如何呢？ --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 218.162.181.103 ※ 编辑: Motownjunk 来自: 218.162.181.103 (09/09 16:52)