作者mrroot (zebras know the way)
看板SFGiants
标题Re: Dodgers tab Colletti as new GM
时间Fri Nov 18 13:47:35 2005
※ 引述《Dkr (野狗幼稚园大班)》之铭言:
: http://0rz.net/150QR
: 我们邻居躲人把 DePo 赶走之後,一直在寻找新的 GM 人选。今天决定了让我们的
: 助理 GM Ned Colletti 投入火坑当中。但愿他在躲人可以过的愉快…
我最近在Columbia Spectator(哥伦比亚大学报)看到一个讨论红袜及道奇GM异动的评论
还蛮有意思的
虽然到处都有关於这两件事的评论 而且其实这篇内容还蛮空泛的
不过是以一个美国大学生的观点来这两件事
所以大家看看就好 笑一下也不错~~~
(没有连结 所以我用打的)
如果想知道我们家的GM从那混出来的 最後在跟你说 :P
"Baseball Decides Dumber is Better" ------ Jake Olson, Nov 1, 2005
For those of us juniors who, like me, have decided to sell our souls, it's
that time of year. Midterms have wrapped up, and now all the big I-banks start
heading to campus to recruit the next round of overpaid, under-rested analysts.
I keep hearing about the advantages we all have, given our prestigious Ivy
League status, but I couldn't help but notice that probably the two most
prominent Ivy Leaguers in the sports world are both now unemployed.
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to Major League Baseball: the only industry in
America where an Ivy League degree hurts you on the job market.
The news that the Satanic baby-eaters who now own my Dodgers decided to can
their GM, Harvard alum Paul DePodesta, after a whole two years on the job, came
as a frustrating and depressing shock. Sure, the Dodgers -- plagued by the more
than 1,400 player games they lost to injury -- had their worst season since
1992, going 71-91. But DePodesta, unlike basically everyone associated with the
Dodgers front office since 1998, actually had a long-term plan to implement,
one that was smart, well-rounded, and fiscally responsible.
On some level, I can understand why DePodesta was fired. It's analogous to
the way I can understand how someone might believe in intelligent design: I
don't respect them, and I think that they have absolutely no grasp on reality,
but I can kind of see where they're coming from.
But the fate of the sports' most famous Yale grad, former Red Sox GM Theo
Epstein, absolutely stumps me. To go Paul Maguire on you, you're talking about
a guy at the top of his profession, working his dream job, about to make tons
of money, and living as the most eligible bachelor in Boston (although, to be
fair, that's a bit like being the wealthiest man in Flint) -- and he walks away
from it all. The more vexing question, though, is this: why did the Red Sox not
do everything in their power to retain the architect of their first champion-
ship team in... wait, how many years was it again? I can never remember.
So now that Epstein and DePodesta are gone, new Rangers GM Jon Daniels, a
Cornell grad, is the only Ivy grad at the helm of a Major League front office.
Several assistant GMs, team presidents, and owners hail from the Ancient Eight,
but the only wheeler-and-dealer left is Daniels, who's been on the job for less
than a month now. Have Major League front offices been so stupid as to absorb
the media backlash against the Moneyball movement and realign their
organizational structures accordingly?
The backlash, led in L.A. by the despicable Bill Plaschke of the Los Angeles
Times, played a major part in the downfall of DePodesta. Plaschke's main
problems with DePodesta were, in order: that he used a laptop computer, and
that he went to Harvard. Now I know that we've become a pretty anti-
intellectual country (see: intelligent design), but that's just absurd. Since
when is education a detriment?
This isn't even an instance of baseball's old guard being averse to new
ideas -- the philosophy espoused by Epstein, DePodesta, Beane et al. is pretty
widely accepted to be an effective way of running a baseball team. If it
wasn't, then some sort of statistical analysis wouldn't be employed by nearly
every team.
For the life of me, I can't figure out why the baseball establishment has
decided to shun DePodesta and Epstein, two of the brighter young front office
talents in the game. But I know that, after spending the last few years of my
life wanting to follow their footsteps, I'm glad I decided to sell my soul. At
least Wall Street appreciates intelligence. Or connections.
--------
Jake Olson is a Columbia College junior majoring in American Studies. Send any
comments to
[email protected]
Answer: Eckerd College (St. Petersburg, FL)
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 156.111.164.117