※ 引述《Rfed (R费)》之铭言： : Top 3 : Jordin Sparks "Wishing On A Star" : 我觉得好无聊 @@ : 编曲很奇怪 : Blake Lewis "Roxanne" : 跟今年The Police在Grammy表演那场很像...minus the variety :p : 基本上我觉得Blake的高音在这首歌表现的不错， : 几个音不仅唱上去而且够浑厚。 : 然後我今天终於发现他高音的问题在哪了 - : 都只是喉呛共鸣，几乎没用到胸腹的力量。 : 但整首歌还是有走音跟脱拍的现象 @@ Blake的声音一直都徘徊在喉咙，很明显就是只用喉腔共鸣。 我就一直在想，这家伙不是五岁就开始学唱歌了吗？（惑） : Jordin Sparks "She Works Hard For The Money" : 唱的很好！果然知道自己优势。 : 她渐渐变成去年的Kat McPhee, 选歌对他来说太重要 : 但选这首歌，为什麽一点感染力都没有？ : 造型丑死了。 真的很丑，到底是怎麽一回事啊？ 不过拿Katharine来比Jordin…是抬举Kat吧？:p Katharine在最後几周荒腔走板的表 演，怎麽看都不能放在第六季的猪肉们相提并论。 : Blake Lewis "This Love" : 当然是比原唱现场好太多 XD : Blake的声音跟表演方式当然是适合这首歌。 : 这首歌在副歌之前唱的非常完美， : 不过副歌this love...开始，我觉得他唱的有点太黏，不够跳 : 但bridge又救起来一点， : 然後他的声音又薄到有点撑不起一首歌。 : 不过是个好表演。 哎呦，Adam本人声音也很薄啊，give him a break。XD 人家明天要来唱歌耶！ : Melinda Doolittle "Nut Bush City Limit" : 怎麽说呢？依旧是技巧无可挑剔的一次演出。 : 但总觉得少了什麽...渲染力吧。 : round 2 : Sure A TIE! : Jordin Sparks "I Who Have Nothing" : (她为什麽穿睡衣上台唱歌？) 真的要枪毙他们家的stylist啦，我的天 XD : 唱的非常好。 : 但真的好老好老喔 (居然还敢在第二轮说 I am 17.. @$WT@$#) : Blake Lewis "When I Get You Alone" : H.O.T.!!!!! : one of his best performaces!!! : 非常的顺耳非常的流畅，声音的表现也不错， : 渲染力强, oh yeah babe! 有种All mixed up coming back，never heard of the song but I'm totally into it! （抱歉啊我跟Robin Thicke不熟）XD : Melinda: "I'm A Woman" : (Please fire the stylist.) : 没感觉，一方面是听过了吧。 : 我觉得太凶，太用力，太雕琢过头(总是听起来很不轻松阿)。 这个我一定要来段VFTW！（受不了这样） Melinda “No Neck” Doolittle sings third. This week she admitted on Jay Leno that she reads the internet sites and knows that people call her Shrek and platypus. Hey, good for her for being able to poke fun at herself too. I almost kind of sort of don’t dislike her as much for being boring. She starts off with Randy’s choice of Whitney Houston’s I Believe in You and Me. She starts off really shaky, it’s actually one of her weakest vocals. And it doesn’t get much better. I didn’t know she could sing this poorly. I mean, it’s not terrible, but it’s certainly much weaker than we’ve seen from her in past weeks. She hits one really bad note at one point too. The judges don’t seem to notice that this is Melinda’s weakest performance to date, as they call it her strongest. Then again, they called Jordin’s You’ ll Never Walk Alone the best Idol vocal ever. By that logic, Sanjaya has had the least interesting Idol hairstyles ever, Paula has taken the least drugs tonight, and Ryan is the most heterosexual man in show business. Hey, this is kind of fun! 没脖子噜噜米第三个唱。这礼拜他在Jay Leno上承认自己有看我们这些网站，也知道 大家叫他噜噜咪/史瑞克。看她这样取笑自己，害我有点不想再表她了，就算她的表演 还是很无聊。（中间形容唱歌不稳哪那些大家自己看噢） 这些评审似乎都没注意到这是Melinda最糟的表现，还说这是她最佳的表现。好吧，他们 还说Jordin的You'll Never Walk Alone是有史以来Idol最佳的歌声。那照这种逻辑， Sanjaya的发型大概是Idol有史以来最无聊的；今晚Paula药吃最少；Ryan是娱乐圈里面 最直的男人。哈哈，这还满好玩的。:p Melinda’s second song is Nutbush City Limits by Tina Turner. This is just another odd choice, as it doesn’t translate well to the Idol stage. Dragging around the mic stand a la Daughtry does not work for her, because it just looks like some extra appendage she has acquired to make up for her lack of neck. The whole performance is manic and weird, but I guess if she’s going for Tina Turner, she’s hitting the nail on the head. Randy says that putting a Tina song on her record will lengthen her career, but what needs lengthening is her neck, not her career. OK, fine, no more neck jokes. But just for now. It’s just that with that ridiculous hair tonight, her neck seems to have crawled even further into her shoulders, making her even more of a human bobblehead. （整段都在开脖子的玩笑。XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD） Last but not least, Melinda reprises I’m a Woman. She needs to remind us of this fact, because I thought she was an ogre starring in her third movie this summer. But apparently I’m an Ogre is not a song, so Woman will have to do. The backup singers come out dressed provocatively and dancing around seductively, which is pretty funny with Melinda fronting them since she has about zero sex appeal. She does sing it really well though, and since she’s in the pimp spot, she just got her ticket to the finale. 最後呢，Melinda唱"I'm a Woman"。她一直得提醒我们这个事实，因为我一直以为他是 本暑假最强续集档的那个主角。不过呢…看来「我是欧格」并不是一首歌，那只好唱「 我是女人」了。後面合音天使跑到前面来搔首弄姿，最有趣的部份是，Melinda凑过去… 完全没有性感到。XD 是唱的很不错啦，不过她卖力的搔首弄姿，她赢得了finale的 门票。 : round 3 : Blake > Jordin > Melinda : 结论： : 本季有很Idol的，有唱将级的，有有一点偶像跟有一点唱将的。 : 谁赢谁输都公平，谁赢谁输也都不让人太有激情。 XD : 但这礼拜终於是不错的一集了。 对啊，明天重点是guest performances。XD --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 140.113.56.189