作者MHC2 (MHCtypeII)
看板PhD
标题[问题] 想请教版上的高手 主编要求revise的意思
时间Thu Apr 10 21:22:15 2014
Paper 1st revise後
主编回信了
还是要求再revise 但主编的要求的内容 不太懂
所以来请教一下版上的高手 感恩!!
Reviewers' comments:
Reviewer #1 (2nd review):
Authors have met my previous concerns adequately.
Editor-in-Chief:
As the Editor-in-Chief of the Journal
I kindly ask you to put your paper in context of publications
of this journal of the last 3 years.
This may contribute to the good quality of the Journal
and may let the reader feel a relation of the papers published.
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc), 来自: 1.162.73.80
※ 文章网址: http://webptt.com/cn.aspx?n=bbs/PhD/M.1397136137.A.8BD.html
1F：推 KeeperOf7Key:要你review一下过去三年该期刊的论文做个连结？ 04/10 21:35
2F：推 Epsilon:叫你多引用那个期刊自己的文章啦，期刊也想冲IF啊。 04/10 21:56
3F：推 b3b4:投该期刊先引该期刊不是潜规则吗？ 表示这工作与该期刊有关啊 04/11 11:46
4F：推 kenet2:我先前也遇过 主编直接说好像本期刊你引用的较少~~ 04/11 16:08
5F：→ kenet2:我二话不说 直接增加5-6个ref. 就ok了~~ 04/11 16:09