http://www.zdnet.com.tw/enterprise/topic/wireless/0,2000085732,20140447,00.htm 又一家P2P网站败诉 这回是Mininova ZDNET新闻专区：Richard Koman 2009/08/27 12:29:02 北欧法院看来持续扫荡P2P 档案交换网站（torrent sites），继 日前瑞典法院下令ISP（网际网路供应商）必须切断The Pirate Bay 连线後，PC Mag报导一家荷兰法院下令Mininova.org必须在30天内清除 站上所有连结至版权档案的tracker。 Mininova本案败诉的关键在於有证据显示，站方十分积极清理/过 滤站上伪装是电影或电视节目档案的恶意软体。法院因此认为，Mini nova应该有能力来过滤掉有着作权的内容，只是站方不愿如此做而已 。 「法院判定Mininova既有能力清除连结至恶意档案的torrent档， 这显示他们有能力来过滤内容。另外，法院也依照原告提出的一份报 告认定，该站有80-90%的torrents都是连结至享有着作权的资料，再 加上该站的分类还包括电影、电视节目与迪士尼等字眼，侵权行为明 确。」 Mininova表示会上诉，但看来情况并不乐观。 「我们并不满意这次的判决，」Mininova共同创办人Eric Dubbelb oer在声明中表示。「这次判决显示Mininova必须重新评估我们的营 运模式，我们会先仔细看过判决书才决定，我们也会考虑上诉。」 -- Mininova 官网的声明 http://tinyurl.com/l6pvl3 Utrecht, August 26th 2009 – Today the Dutch Court of Utrecht ruled that BitTorrent platform Mininova acts unlawful. Mininova considers to appeal this judgment. The court did not agree with Brein on all demands. Specifically, it ruled that Mininova does not infringe copyright and neighboring rights. The court also found Mininova can not be expected to remove files that are “reasonably likely” refer to infringing material. Remarkably, the verdict does not give any consideration to the fact that Mininova has developed a content filter for Brein, nor to the cooperation between Mininova and other organizations of rights holders. This surprises Mininova, because it has always stressed the importance of cooperation. Erik Dubbelboer, co-founder of Mininova: “We are obviously not satisfied with this ruling. The result of this ruling for Mininova is that we have to reevaluate our business operations. At this time, we cannot determine what this will actually entail or imply. We will have to examine the verdict thoroughly first. We are considering to appeal this judgment.” -- --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 219.81.204.98