作者thrush (发哥)
看板Ornithology
标题Re: [讯息] 预告:Clements名录今年版的变动
时间Sun Nov 13 22:55:13 2011
※ 引述《thrush (发哥)》之铭言:
: 我直接写信问作者姊姊了XDXDXD
: 请静候佳音~
Dear Dali,
Thank you for your message. S. n. nivicola is the subspecies that
occurs in the Himalayas. The species nivicola is split from aluco
primarily on the basis of its very different vocalizations, but it
also has notable morphological differences. The treatment of the
nivicola group as part of aluco could only be maintained as long as
there was no knowledge of its vocalizations, but now is untenable.
I have not studies the other two subspecies so cannot confirm whether
they are valid or not.
I hope this helps.
Best wishes,
Pamela C. Rasmussen
也就是说,S. n. nivicola的叫声及型态与其他的亚种不同,
所以被独立出来成一个种
因为他没有对S. a. yamadae 和 S. a. ma作研究,
所以没有处理这两个亚种。
结论:Clements 6.6并没有问题
台湾的亚种S.a. yamadae仍然属於Strix aluca
Strix nivicola 只有一个指名亚种 Strix nivicola nivicola
真是一个好科学家,有几分证据说几分话。
--
阿飘就像断了线的风筝
他要去找你
我也没办法
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 61.217.155.171
1F:推 avocet:证实我的猜想:他们只做了喜马拉雅地区的族群。 11/13 23:35
2F:推 FoxBird:推这讨论串,获益良多! 11/14 21:23