作者s9527206 (悠)
看板Nationals
标题[情报] John Sickels 对交易得到/失去之新秀简评
时间Wed Aug 3 01:28:42 2011
这篇内容其实跟我之前写的以及 abc12812大 那篇BA报告大致相似,反正就加减看吧。
Gomes 交易案:送出 Chris Manno 和 Bill Rhinehart
http://tinyurl.com/45xgb89
Chris Manno, LHP: The Nationals drafted Manno in the 26th round in 2010 from
Duke University. A 6-3, 170 pound lefty, Manno had a 1.04 ERA with a
spectacular 69/15 K/BB in 43 innings for Low-A Hagerstown, with 20 hits
allowed and 12 saves. All of his numbers are terrific this year, but he has
average stuff, throwing an 86-89 MPH fastball along with an average slider
and curve. He's tough on lefties and could be a LOOGY-type bullpen asset at
higher levels. Despite his excellent numbers, he's a Grade C prospect pending
data against better competition.
简评:今年各项数字都十分优异,但 stuff 只有平均程度:快速球约 86-89 MPH,
搭配平均水准的滑球和曲球。专杀左打,未来可以期待成长为不错的一人左。
不过数据必须等上升到更高层级後才能证明是真是假。
评价:C
Bill Rhinehart, OF: Rhinehart was drafted in the 11th round by the Nationals
in 2007, from the University of Arizona. He's having a fine year in Double-A,
with a .283/.376/.587 mark and 21 homers for Harrisburg, with 39 walks and 59
strikeouts in 276 at-bats. His tools are mediocre and he's already 26 years
old, but he's got some pop in his bat and might have some use as a reserve.
At worst he's good roster filler for the upper minors. Grade C.
简评:今年在2A打得非常出色,三围.283/.376/.587 还附带21支HR。工具平平,而且
已经26岁了,不过炮瓦还算可以,也许有机会长成大联盟替补,最差也可以放
在高阶农场陪其他公子练球。
评价:C
Jerry Hairston, Jr. 交易案:得到 Eric Komatsu
http://tinyurl.com/3prdzn8
Eric Komatsu, OF: The Brewers drafted Komatsu in the eighth round in 2008,
from Cal State Fullerton. He missed most of 2009 with injuries to his
hamstring and wrist, plus complications from a concussion, but returned to
health in 2010 and hit .323/.413/.442 for High-A Brevard County, with 68
walks and 28 steals. This year he's hitting .294/.393/.416 with 53 walks, 44
strikeouts, and 13 steals for Double-A Huntsville. A 23-year-old left-handed
hitter, Komatsu lacks power but has decent speed. He has excellent strike
zone judgment and is a very polished hitter, but as a tweener-type who lacks
big power, he'll likely fit best as a reserve outfielder. I gave him a C+
pre-season but he's probably more on the upper edge of a straight Grade C as
a useful future role player.
简评:没炮瓦,速度不错,选球很好,完成度很高,预计是个 4th OF。
评价:C级中的霸主(还是C级)
Jason Marquis 交易案:得到 Zach Walters
http://tinyurl.com/3dfrq9o
Zach Walters, INF: Walters was drafted by Arizona in the 9th round in 2010,
from the University of San Diego. He hit .302/.338/.440 for Yakima in the
Northwest League after signing, swiping 14 bases. Assigned to South Bend in
the Midwest League for 2011, he's been a strong performer with a
.302/.377/.485 mark so far, with 42 walks and 96 strikeouts in 361 at-bats.
He's swiped 12 bases, but has been caught 10 times. A 21-year-old
switch-hitter, Walters has an average throwing arm and average range, and has
spent time at second base, third base, and shortstop this year. Second is his
best position, but his versatility would make him an attractive roster option
if he continues to hit at higher levels. He's got doubles power and decent
plate discipline, but his strikeout rate is rather high, which warns some
adjustments may be needed. I rated him a Grade C in my book this year but an
upgrade to C+ is plausible.
简评:平均水准的臂力和守备范围,今年守过二三游,其中又以守二垒表现最佳。
功能性强,未来如果能在更高层级将打击表现继续维持住或许会是蛮不错的
选择。拥有干二垒打的炮瓦,本垒板纪律也不错,但被三振率太高了,一些
适当的调整是有必要的。
评价:C,有机会升级成C+
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 118.166.131.166
1F:推 Ryushuier:我其实觉得Gomes,把那两个新秀 丢掉有点可惜 08/03 01:44
2F:→ s9527206:如果我们能拿到三明治补偿选秀搞不好就有赚啦:) 08/03 01:46
3F:→ s9527206:不过 Manno 今年在小联盟数据真的颇杀,K/9 14.6 08/03 01:47
※ 编辑: s9527206 来自: 118.166.131.166 (08/03 01:49)
4F:→ s9527206:Rhinehart 就算了,能用的机会说实在不大。 08/03 01:49
5F:推 Ryushuier:因为26岁了,突然就想到罗国辉,我都忘记他有补偿选秀 08/03 01:51
6F:→ Ryushuier:现在看到Morgan 这麽杀, 就可惜点 ;国民CF呢 XD 08/03 01:53
7F:→ Ryushuier:可惜没换到盗垒王那一只 08/03 01:54
8F:→ j07242054:但Morgan的个性实在............................ 08/03 03:01