※ 引述《tkyoung (MA NY Conquered)》之铭言： : 标题: [INFO] Face-guarding is not a foul on NFL : 时间: Tue Jan 30 01:28:21 2007 : -- :

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc) : ◆ From: 24.60.248.166 : 推 GypsyEyes:呵呵，Patriots应该是最没资格指责裁判的球队 01/30 21:59 : 推 GypsyEyes:老实说，文章最後一段写得蛮没品的 01/30 22:04 : 推 Agency:不过那得在那段写的不是事实的情况下才成立 01/30 23:09 : 推 NCAA:可以偷偷推一楼嘛 XD 01/31 00:01 : 推 tlchen:Tuck rule 吗? 那是个 rule, 而且经讨论後, 现仍保存 01/31 06:20 : → tlchen:可以说规则对 Patriots 有利, 但我看不出跟裁判有何关系? 01/31 06:21 : → tlchen:裁判只是跟据对 Patriots 那场有利的规则, 做出正确判决 01/31 06:22 : 推 NCAA:问题就是Tom Brady到底有没有往前传吧...啧啧... 01/31 09:01 : 推 NCAA:Tuck rule是如果QB有往前传的动作时才成立 01/31 09:04 : → NCAA:但如果没有往前传的动作就来引用Tuck rule......(默) 01/31 09:04 : 推 NCAA:当然 裁判是认为有往前传的动作...... 01/31 09:07 : → NCAA:刚刚从看了一下影片 Tom Brady有往前传的动作... 01/31 09:08 : → NCAA:可是那是个假动作........XD 01/31 09:09 : → NCAA:就在他收球的同时 就被tackle了... 01/31 09:09 : → NCAA:所以到底要怎麽算呢？ (摊手) 01/31 09:09 : → NCAA:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RMMa7cZb2Jc 01/31 09:10 : → NCAA:大约从3"28开始看 01/31 09:10 : 推 tlchen:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuck_rule 01/31 16:13 ^ NFL Rule 3, Section 21, Article 2, Note 2: "When a Team A player is holding the ball to pass it forward, any intentional forward movement of his arm starts a forward pass, even if the player loses possession of the ball as he is attempting to tuck it back toward his body. Also, if the player has tucked the ball into his body and then loses possession, it is a fumble." 所以裁判是就前半段的规则认为那是一个incomplete pass 不过又有後半段的规则，这样就变的很玄呀～～ 到底Tom Brady是要tuck it back toward his body? 还是 tuck the ball into his body? 这大概讲一百年都不会有答案 (所以要怪Charles Woodson太早去tackle Tom Brady了～XD) 只是我比较好奇的就是 为什麽NFL会有Tcuk Rule这种规定哩？ --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 60.248.32.133