SKY 球迷 评语 Edwin van der Sar 7 7.5 Clean sheet John O'Shea 7 7.1 Sound Chris Smalling 7 7.3 Able deputy Nemanja Vidic 8 8.0 Impressive Patrice Evra 7 7.1 Rested at interval Anderson 8 7.7 Industrious Ryan Giggs 8 8.7 Evergreen Michael Carrick 6 6.2 Early injury Wayne Rooney 8 7.9 Improving Dimitar Berbatov 9 9.7 Brilliant Nani 7 6.3 Rather greedy Darron Gibson (Sub) 7 6.5 Impressed Michael Owen (Sub) 6 6.2 Tried hard http://www.skysports.com/football/user_ratings/0,19768,11065_3284146,00.html M.E.N http://tinyurl.com/4focmu5 Edwin van der Sar - 6 Measured Scholes-like pass was root of United's fourth! Nothing else to do as a keeper Patrice Evra - 6 Easily on top of the Bentley threat and had some decent attacks himself Chris Smalling - 7 Birmingham didn't offer much to test him but what he was asked to do was done with ease John O'Shea - 7 Eased back into it with a solid enough return to starting action for the first time since November Nemanja Vidic - 7 This was an easy afternoon for someone enjoying the formidable form he is showing Anderson - 8 Non-stop bundle of energy who kept Reds ticking over at high tempo Michael Carrick - 6 Early tackle from Hleb left him limping before he was taken off after 24 minutes Ryan Giggs - 7 55 minutes largely of old time Giggs with a key hand in three of United's four goals Nani - 8 Had Brum on back foot all the time. Not everything came off but goal was a beauty Wayne Rooney - 8 Early second half miss summed up his goal torment but key role in three goals Dimitar Berbatov - 9 Virtually everything went right for the Bulgarian in another memorable effort Substitutes Fabio - 6 (sub Evra 45) Rafael in disguise? Darron Gibson - 6 (sub Carrick 24) Solid contribution Michael Owen - 6 (sub Giggs 55) Decent cameo -- ★ ╔╦═╮╔╮ ╭╔╮ ╭╔╦═╮ ╔╮╔╮╭╦═╮╔╮═╮ ☆ ☆ ╠╬╦╯╠╣ ║╠╣ ║╠╣ ║ ╠╣╠╣╠╬═╣╠╣ ║ ★ ★ ╰╝╰╯╰╝═╯╰╝═╯╚╯═╯ ╰╰╯╯╰╝ ╰╰╝ ╰ ☆ ☆ SCORING MACHINE︰ Ruud van Nistelrooy ★ ╔╮═╮╭╦╦╮╭╦═╮╭╦╦╮╔╦═╮╔╮ ╔╦═╮╭╦═╭═╦╮╮ ╔╮ ╠╣ ║ ╠╣ ╚╩╦╮ ╠╣ ╠╬╣ ╠╣ ╠╬╦╯╠╣ ║ ╠╣╚═╬╣ ╰╝ ╰╰╩╩╯╰═╩╝ ╚╝ ╚╩═╯╰╩═╯╰╝╰╯╰╩═╯═╩╯╰═╩╝ --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 125.224.188.220