作者jackshai (胜机不足就要拖)
看板Magic
标题Re: [情报]M12预览开始~!!!
时间Tue Jun 28 09:24:49 2011
Vengeful Pharaoh 2BBB
Creature - Zombie
Deathtouch
Whenever combat damage is dealt to your or a planeswalker you control,
if Vengeful Pharaoh is in your graveyard, destroy target attacking creature,
then put Vengeful Pharaoh on top of your library.
痾...法老的触发式异能包含了一个"Intervening IF"的叙述,以中文来讲,就是内文
里面的"如果"这两个字是在整段触发式异能的<中间>,而不是<开头>。如果是这种叙述的
话,则在触发以及结算这项启动式异能时都要符合"IF"那一段的条件。不符合的话就不会
成功结算。
这在完整规则里面被称为<intervening "if clause" rule>。
以下是完整规则:
603.4. A triggered ability may read "When/Whenever/At [trigger event],
if [condition], [effect]." When the trigger event occurs, the ability checks
whether the stated condition is true. The ability triggers only if it is;
otherwise it does nothing. If the ability triggers, it checks the stated
condition again as it resolves. If the condition isn't true at that time,
the ability is removed from the stack and does nothing. Note that this
mirrors the check for legal targets. This rule is referred to as the
"intervening 'if' clause" rule. (The word "if" has only its normal English
meaning anywhere else in the text of a card; this rule only applies to an
"if" that immediately follows a trigger condition.)
: 2. 假设他触发多次
: 第一个堆叠解完 法老已经回牌库顶了
: 等到解第二个堆叠 根据完整规则603.4
: 因为不符合if条件 所以整个异能会被移除
: 後面类推
2.是对的。
------
顺带一提,如果IF出现在内文叙述的开头而不是中间,则他会照一般人所认知的去
处理~。
然後在同一次战斗伤害分配中,法老的异能应该只会触发一次。如果会触发多次的话,
内文叙述应该是:
Whenever "A CREATURE" deals combat damage to your or a planeswalker you control,
if Vengeful Pharaoh is in your graveyard, destroy target attacking
creature,then put Vengeful Pharaoh on top of your library.
有"A CREATURE"的话,就是一个生物算一次~
(好像这样写才对....ORZ)
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.24.60.147
※ 编辑: jackshai 来自: 114.24.60.147 (06/28 09:28)
1F:推 mouse8899:咦?所以是会触发多次??? 06/28 09:28
2F:→ jackshai:我还没打完XD 06/28 09:28
3F:→ jackshai:他没有写"每当一个生物打到你",就只会确认你有没受伤。 06/28 09:29
4F:推 parallax:简单来说会触发多次,但第一次结算的时候法老就回家了 06/28 09:29
5F:→ jackshai:!! 会触发多次嘛@@? 06/28 09:31
6F:推 parallax:喔 不对耶 我看错 只会触发1次 = = 06/28 09:32
7F:推 aeolus1215:印象中by a creature只有用在becomes blocked叙述 06/28 09:33
8F:→ aeolus1215:似乎没有看过接在damage is dealt to you後面的 06/28 09:33
※ 编辑: jackshai 来自: 114.24.60.147 (06/28 09:36)
9F:推 xbit:因为你可能档很多只生物,或被很多只生物档 06/28 10:09
10F:→ xbit:destroy target attacking creature 我想光这句就很明白了 06/28 10:33
11F:→ a020012393:"target" 06/28 11:14
12F:推 wuluke:有人有发老的图片吗 06/28 11:43
13F:→ wuluke:法老 06/28 11:44
14F:推 asdX:怎麽觉得简单的问题越来越复杂 本来很确信->慢慢开始怀疑自己 06/28 20:29
15F:→ j3307002:所以即使你被多於一个生物打也只会触发一次? 06/29 00:57
16F:→ j3307002:而且也仅限於战斗伤害 06/29 00:57
17F:→ jackshai:回楼上 YES~ 06/29 09:47
18F:推 j3307002:感谢 06/30 01:54