※ 引述《tinder17 (devil's cut)》之铭言： : Erotica 是我最爱的玛丹娜专辑耶，这张的音乐在当时，甚至是现在 : 我认为都是很成功的，所以其实我并不是很喜欢她现在的电子曲风。 : 英国Ｇｕａｒｄｉａｎ杂志对新专辑评论的结语是： : 　 : 　　　　The album's problem has nothing to do with controversy : 　　　　or extreme points of view. This time, there just aren't : enough good songs. : http://www.guardian.co.uk/arts/reviews/story/0,11712,933936,00.html : 　 Madonna: "The critics have been writing me off for 20 years. That's nothing new. As far as I know I still have plenty of fans and sell lots of records. Do I care what critics say about me? No, and I don't read reviews." Undercover She is a true superstar 'American Life' never strays far from social comment or religious statements...Madonna gives an extremely confessional set of lyrics on this album Boston Herald ***1/2* In addition to the inexplicably warm electronics, ``American Life'' also contains some of the best and most dynamic singing of Madonna's career. E! online B+ Trust us, the hits from American Life will be her all-grown-up ballads ("Intervention," "Love Profusion") Slant Magazine 3 1/2 out of 5 Stars .......the influence of Joni Mitchell, an early Madonna favorite, seems to be finally floating to the surface People Magazine Great American Dream Call it futuristic folk.....Nothing Fails .....is a "Like a Prayer" for the 21st century Barnes & Noble Madonna has created a mature, focused collection of songs that sometimes soothes, often provokes, and sometimes gets her fans into the groove USA Today 3 1/2 our of 4 More prayerful than playful, Madonna narrates her faith-based autobiography with style and sincerity !! Advocate Magazine All-American girl Madonna's latest CD makes a fascinating exploration of her own complicated American Life Newsweek "American Life" eventually warms up...It turns out that the woman really can sing when she's not so hellbent on proving it. BBC 'American Life' succeeds as an album where 'Music' failed. It has attitude and balls - just like a good Madonna record should have. Boston Globe The mother of reinvention shows an introspective side...With "American Life," Madonna takes a sincere and tender turn NME 7 out of 10 New York Post 3.5 stars This is an excellent album musically, but more important, it's a ground-breaking concept where music lovers and the artist win. Rolling Stone *** LA Times *** A former material girl, materially changed..., Madonna, whose vocals are more confident and convincing than ever Dotmusic 7 out of 10 What's remarkable is that 'American Life' is still a great album --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.csie.ntu.edu.tw) ◆ From: 210.85.82.84