作者ccshan (善终结)
看板Linguistics
标题Re: [请益] 想请问 presuppose 和entails的最大差异
时间Fri Feb 26 05:59:21 2010
※ 引述《noamchomsky ()》之铭言:
: ※ 引述《pianoandme ( )》之铭言:
: : 想请问一下 到底要怎麽清楚的分辨presuppose 和entailmaent
: : 例如 下面这个例子 到底是presuppose 还是entailment
: : 一开始我是觉得 都是entailment 可是後来又觉得好像是presuppose ..
: : a) Tom is bigger than Mary
: : b) Mary is smaller than Tom
: entailment
一般分辨的一个办法是前句 negate 以後是否还能接後句。
例如 Tom is not bigger than Mary
或 It is not the case that Tom is bigger than Mary
就不能接 Mary is smaller than Tom
: : a)The minister blams her secretary for leaking the memo to the press
: : b)The memo was leaked to the press
: presupposition
但 The minister does not blame her secretary for leaking the memo to the press
或 It is not the case that the minister blames her secretary for leaking the memo to the press
就可接 The memo was leaked to the press
--
▼ 单中杰.
[email protected].善终结
▼
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 70.18.34.211
1F:推 pianoandme:thank you 02/27 20:42