前一阵子有讨论提到部分语言如梵语有voiced aspirated stops 刚刚读书看到这段 "In Hindi there is a series of stops sometimes INCORRECTLY referred to as VOICED ASPIRATED STOPS that make use of whispery voice (murmur)." 这意思是说这类声音应该算是murmur，只是不同glottal state造成的影响 我想Hindi和梵语很接近，发音应该可以比较 那到底有没有真的voiced aspirated stops呢? 我之前一份作业有类似的问题 提到aspirated n是不可能的，因为 "Aspiration indicates a delay in the onset of voicing of a vowel following the release of a voiceless stop; nasals can't be aspirated because they are voiced." 简单讲就是voiced nasal不会有aspiration 因为会有aspiration是前面stop的voiceless-ness延後了下一个vowel voicing的时间 我想这种说明应该不限於nasals，应该包括所有voiced stops 所以实际上应该没有voiced aspirated stops，这样对吗? --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 118.166.48.2