作者echo0520 (忙)
看板LadyGaga
标题[分享] 对於Gaga演唱会的评论
时间Sun Dec 6 16:15:12 2009
在网站上看到了一个对於Gaga的评论
虽然他不喜欢这场演唱会 不过我觉得可以让大家看一下他分析的点
Gaga迷们也别生气 这只是他个人意见喔~
我贴上全文,重要的部份有简单的翻译
---------------------------------------------------------------
Lady Gaga's stardom turns cold on stage
By Sam Adams
For The Inquirer
'I'm feeling particularly slutty tonight," Stefani Germanotta purred to a
sold-out Susquehanna Bank Center on Thursday night.
Known to her fans - as well as anyone who's passed within hailing distance of
a working radio or TV set in the last year - as Lady Gaga, she arrived with
the kind of explosive force that can incinerate artists unprepared for the
spotlight.
这段提到Lady Gaga的火红程度
Since the success of her insidious, inescapable single "Poker Face," Gaga has
staged a blizzard of reinvention, from sex kitten to bondage queen, as well
as what might be a visitor from a far more stylish future. Her album The
Fame, and its brief follow-up, The Fame Monster, are gratifyingly solid and
diverse, drawing on an unabashed love of funk, disco, and electropop that
has, somewhat miraculously, transcended the borders of the dance-music ghetto.
提到Gaga的音乐综合了各种不同元素,两张专辑音乐相当多变
But what works in the controlled medium of a photo shoot or the brief span of
a music video doesn't necessarily translate to the stage. Lady Gaga may have
the mechanics of pop stardom down pat, but as a headlining performer, she is
still a work in progress. Her two-hour set - longer by half an hour than all
her recorded works combined - was full of dead spots and long breaks for
costume and scenery changes that sapped the show's momentum and disrupted its
groove.
虽然Gaga的照片或者是MV相当惊人,但他在舞台上表现却还需进步。演唱会整场表演
充满了换衣服或者是换布景的空档,打断了整场表演的感觉
As a character, Lady Gaga is an attention-starved dominatrix. Throwing
herself to the stage between songs, she invited the audience to ravish her,
and throughout the show she kept up a constant refrain: "Do you love me? Do
you think I'm sexy?" Occasionally, her voice would jump from a baby-doll coo
to a raspy scream, as if revealing the needy monster beneath the seductive
exterior. But really, she was just trading one act for another. When she
dropped the masks, she was more inclined to gush, whether in person or via a
video in which she proclaimed her fans "kings" and "queens," demoting herself
to court jester.
「Lady Gaga」这个角色,似乎无时无刻都需要别人注意。在歌曲与歌曲之间他常问大家
「你们爱我吗?」「你们觉得我很性感吗?」而她的声音有时会从娃娃音突然变成沙哑
的吼叫,似乎是在显露出在他性感外衣底下的饥渴的怪物。不论怎样,这些都只是表演
他卸下面具後,最常说的就是她的歌迷是「国王」与「皇后」,把他自己降级为「弄臣」
Apart from fleeting appearances by a guitarist and drummer, who joined her on
the piano ballad "Speechless," her onstage company consisted solely of
backing dancers, whose rote choreography never matched the outlandish
provocations of Gaga's outerwear. Madonna and Kylie Minogue, to name two of
her obvious predecessors, make a show of treating their dancers like an
extended family, an interaction that adds a note of spontaneity to
performances that can seem like elaborate karaoke nights. Gaga seemed
isolated on stage, and oddly tentative, as if not quite ready to assume
stardom as her right rather than a privilege contingent on each passing
instant.
除了在Speechless表演时,吉他手与鼓手的短暂出现之外,舞台上除了他只有背景舞者,
而那些舞者根本和Gaga搭不上线。玛丹娜和凯莉米诺表演时总是把舞群视为家庭,
舞台上的互动让人觉得相当欢乐。但Gaga好像被孤立在舞台上,每分每秒将
她的明星光芒视为她特有的偶发事件而非她的权利
A little humility in a pop star is a good thing, but too much and the spell
is broken. Need the audience too much, and they stop needing you.
对一个明星来说,一些谦逊固然是好事,但太多的时候,你的魔力就消失了。
当你太需要观众时,他们会不再需要你
-------------------------------------------------------------
有些地方不太清楚 像是
"Gaga seemed isolated on stage, and oddly tentative, as if not quite ready
to assume stardom as her right rather than a privilege contingent
on each passing instant"
也许是指Gaga还缺少了所谓的「大将之风」,反而是仅抓住她能够充分展现自己的
每一刻,然後拼了命的想演给大家看的意思吧。
--------------------------------------------------------------
不论如何,还是期待Gaga来台开唱。缺失人人都会有,重点是会不会进步
Gaga加油:)
※ 编辑: echo0520 来自: 203.75.155.16 (12/06 16:18)
1F:推 nosweating:我觉得gaga还太年轻 欠磨练与经验是一定的 我倒希望她 12/06 16:20
2F:→ lambaby:其实我也看过很多大排演出~并非每个人都天生的表演者~~ 12/06 16:20
3F:→ nosweating:不要在这段时间把光环都用尽 希望她未来可以继续前进 12/06 16:21
4F:→ lambaby:我相信gaga还年轻~之後一定会更好更棒的~ 12/06 16:21
5F:→ lambaby:to nosweating~我不是故意的~哈哈 12/06 16:22
6F:推 nosweating:to lambaby XD 我也不好意思把你切断了 :P 12/06 16:37
7F:→ cc60230tw:哈 楼上和楼楼上混合了 12/06 17:21
8F:→ suweiQQ:也有人形容她像追求fame的傀儡,玛丹娜的dancer形象非常鲜 12/06 17:29
9F:→ suweiQQ:明(例如Cloud就有很多fans),他们也有为娜姐庆生! 12/06 17:29
10F:→ suweiQQ:ps.Gaga的第二代dancer中有一个白人很像183club的祝帆纲XD 12/06 17:30
11F:→ suweiQQ:在VMA的狗仔队和AMVA的罗曼死可以找到 12/06 17:30
12F:→ suweiQQ:另外和舞者互动不错的还有Gwen Stefani的Harajuku Girls! 12/06 17:41
13F:推 SqueezeMe:Madonna早期演唱会也不怎麽好看 12/06 18:09
14F:推 jonafu29:觉得还蛮中肯的~不过我相信阿嘎以後一定会更好 12/06 19:11
15F:推 kathpope:中肯+1~对於新人就这样剖析的角度报导也就代表这记者很 12/06 19:18
16F:→ kathpope:看重Gaga~ 12/06 19:18
17F:→ kathpope:那个像祝帆纲的舞者在VMA有跟Gaga solo耶~ 12/06 19:22
18F:推 eric760416:换衣服空档太长喔?是因为服装太难换了吗?还是道具太多? 12/06 20:26
19F:→ kathpope:应该都多吧~假发很多顶耶@@ 12/06 21:20
20F:→ ayu2006:我觉得GaGa越来越有玛丹娜那种国际天后的风范了 12/06 21:54
21F:→ hoshiru:还早的很吧!? 至少等个25年再说XD 12/06 22:35
22F:推 hownever:对一个新人而言,现在都是在累积经验,加油吧 12/06 23:14
23F:→ kathpope:Gaga加油~继续进化XD 12/07 00:26
24F:→ anselsto:我觉得GAGA这年纪 LIV功力已很了得了耶 看看其他同辈的.. 12/07 17:56
25F:→ anselsto: ^E 12/07 17:57
26F:推 carb628:中肯阿 不过lady gaga跟madonna都有义裔血统 天后潜力... 12/09 01:28
27F:推 ufo866:Gaga问"Do you think I am sexy?"的影片 虽然是文章之後 12/12 23:59