作者ChesterB (很难想)
看板KingofPop
标题[情报] Hold My Hand乐评
时间Mon Nov 15 22:13:46 2010
http://tinyurl.com/257pw5y
Reviews: Hold My Hand
There won't be any controversy about the vocals on this one. The only
question is how long until it scales the charts (if word of mouth is any
indication, minutes after its midnight premier it was already trending #1 on
Twitter around the world). "Hold My Hand" is a simple, but powerful song that
embodies so much of what fans loved about Michael Jackson. Like U2's "One" it
is a "love song" that expands outward, making the personal something more
profound and universal. With its catchy chorus and majestic crescendo it has
all the makings of a big hit (perhaps Jackson's first #1 in the U.S. since
"You Are Not Alone" in 1995).
关於这首歌的歌声真假 没有争议 唯一的问题是这首歌甚麽时候才会登上排行榜
(如果说出口的事情是一个指标 在午夜首发後这已经是Twitter关键热门字的第一)
Hold My Hand是首简单但却很有力量的歌 有很多MJ歌迷喜爱的元素 就像U2的One
这是一首充满爱的歌 并且由个人向外扩展到全世界 他有非常动人的旋律 这将使这首歌
会成为热门歌曲 (或许是麦可在95年you are not alone之後的全美冠军单曲)
(这个评论人还真是看好 和有信心阿XD)
Critics will undoubtedly point to the song's excessive flourishes and
sentimentalism. Clearly, in his updated production, Akon was aiming bigger
than the 2008 version that leaked online. It works, however, among other
reasons, because of the context. This is a catharsis song for many listeners.
And that's what the soaring gospel-infused ending provides. There will always
be a place (and need) for songs that bring people together, reminding us to
love, bridge divides and connect.
毫无疑问评论会指出这首歌感情太多了 很显然在阿肯的最後完成版 他比08年的版本所
设定的目标还要更大 另一方面也有其他原因 因为歌词内容 这是一首宣导的歌曲 而这也
是这首歌结尾所带给你的感觉 总是会有一首歌会带领所有人团结 提醒我们爱 让我们在分
列中再次团结起来
Yet for all its lavishness and grandiosity, there are some nice subtle
touches as well. The intro is a variation of Pachelbel's Canon in D Major
(Jackson was an avid lover of classical music). Jackson's vocal is
understated, but effective, capturing a combination of joy, yearning, and
sadness. The opening lyric ("This life don't last forever...") is a poignant
reminder of the transience of life.
是的这首歌或许有些太繁复奢华了 但是却有很多很棒的小细节 开头的帕海贝尔D大调卡农
的变奏 (麦可是古典乐的爱好者) 麦可的歌声没有这麽显着 但却非常有影响力的抓住了
所有愉快 怀念 和感伤的综合情绪 开头的歌词提醒了大家生命转瞬间的感伤
If a song like this can't knock off the pop-lite of Kesha and Katy Perry it
says far more about the state of pop music than Michael Jackson. "Hold My
Hand" isn't "Man in the Mirror," but it's a nice consolation gift to fill the
void of his absence.
如果像这样的歌还不能打败现在流行歌坛的Ke$ha和Katy Perry等人 我们就知道当今流行
乐坛的现状已没啥好说了 Hold My Hand不是镜中人 但是一首很好安抚人的礼物来填补
MJ已经不在的空洞
Listen to "Hold My Hand" at michaeljackson.com.
Jackson's first posthumous album, Michael, will be released December 14, 2010.
Joe Vogel is the author of three books, including the forthcoming Man in the
Music: The Creative Life and Work of Michael Jackson (Sterling 2011).
--
In a world filled with hate, we must still dare to hope.
In a world filled with anger, we must still dare to comfort.
In a world filled with despair, we must still dare to dream.
In a world filled with distrust, we must still dare to believe.
~~~~By Michael Jackson
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 173.59.231.40
1F:推 Mr7:抓住综合情绪那段好贴切....听完後又温暖又感伤 11/15 22:22
2F:推 Foucault:看完这篇有感动到想流泪的fu...这首歌真的把情绪抓得很好 11/15 22:25
3F:→ Foucault:非常有渲染力,很美却又没有距离感。 11/15 22:25
4F:推 breakofdawn:这首若是拿不下冠军,坦白讲MJ美国的冠军单曲就会止於 11/15 22:43
5F:→ breakofdawn:You Are Not Alone,但是这首冠军的机会个人认为非常非 11/15 22:44
6F:→ breakofdawn:常高(以上两点纯为个人推测) 11/15 22:45
7F:推 Syg:推~~~~~~ 11/15 22:46
8F:推 Heal:这首真的是MJ元素的一切 11/15 22:47
9F:推 iloveck:反覆听了很多遍,一种温暖又带着淡淡的哀伤包围着我。 11/15 22:49
10F:推 lemon249:歌声真的很温柔~很感人 11/15 23:03
11F:推 moon777:真的很温暖,好想赶快买到单曲 11/15 23:08
12F:推 oldtrafford:这篇写的赞啦 我期待这个作者MJ歌曲的分析书 11/15 23:28
13F:推 stemuse:好温馨励志向上到不行的一首歌喔~~~很有情感 推!! 11/15 23:44
14F:推 fanny423:这首歌很温暖,听着会有激励却又平复心情的感觉 11/16 03:35
15F:推 pongui:听到我头发麻快颤抖了,太好听了 11/16 14:01
16F:推 Sprout:我也是听到浑身颤抖 MJ的歌总是可以给我力量! 11/17 13:45