作者tobetwob (WHO FCTC 菸草减害专家)
看板Gossiping
标题[问卦] 用医疗器材抽加热菸有什麽疗效?(发钱)
时间Thu Mar 14 21:31:18 2024
大家好，我是世界卫生组织 菸草减害专家 王郁扬
https://i.imgur.com/xnVyBc9.jpg
每五推发50P，发到爆为止。
--------------
吸烟对身体很不健康，请问用医疗器材抽加热菸有什麽疗效吗？
新北市电子烟及加热式菸具管理自治条例第四条写：
「未经取得药品许可证或医疗器材许可证之电子烟、加热式菸具及其零组件，不得制造、输
入、贩卖、展示、广告、促销或赞助。」
(资料来源：新北市卫生局
https://www.health.ntpc.gov.tw/basic/?mode=detail&node=8796)
因此，
在新北市，加热菸具属於医疗器材。
再根据《医疗器材管理法》第三条写：
本法所称医疗器材，指仪器、器械、用具、物质、软体、体外诊断试剂及其相关物品，其
设计及使用系以药理、免疫、代谢或化学以外之方法作用於人体，而达成下列主要功能之
一者：
一、诊断、治疗、缓解或直接预防人类疾病。
二、调节或改善人体结构及机能。
三、调节生育。
前项医疗器材之分类、风险分级、品项、判定原则及其他相关事项之办法，由中央主管机
关定之。
第一项第二款属非侵入性、无危害人体健康之虞及使用时毋需医事人员协助之辅具，得报
请中央主管机关核准，免列为前项医疗器材之品项。
前项辅具系指协助身心障碍者改善或维护身体功能、构造，促进活动及参与，或便利其照
顾者照顾之装置、设备、仪器及软体等产品。
(资料来源：全国法规资料库
https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawSingle.aspx?pcode=L0030106&flno=3)
请问新北市用医疗器材抽加热菸有什麽疗效？
--
https://i.imgur.com/621ia33.jpg https://i.imgur.com/PPmqCOI.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/0YO0JoW.jpg https://i.imgur.com/iCELafr.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/R6j4v1C.png WHO FCTC 菸草减害专家 王郁扬Danny(Yu-Yang) Wang
https://i.imgur.com/xnVyBc9.jpg https://i.imgur.com/2Fi1w1C.jpg
台湾禁菸联盟 ABC#TAIWAN、无烟台湾基金会FSFT、台湾菸草减害协会TTHRA。
台湾威卜 菸草减害网路媒体 VAPE TAIWAN
https://vapetaiwan-media.com/
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc), 来自: 1.200.76.162 (台湾)
※ 文章网址: https://webptt.com/cn.aspx?n=bbs/Gossiping/M.1710423084.A.CA9.html
1F：推 chubby31190: 首推 钱 101.8.14.125 03/14 21:31
2F：推 losec0614: 钱 1.200.49.22 03/14 21:31
3F：推 kyosukeakiba: 抽菸过时了，不要抽菸！ 114.44.134.162 03/14 21:32
4F：推 ArSaBuLu: 大铁表示:223.140.111.215 03/14 21:32
---
5F：推 mottohayaku: 140.109.16.77 03/14 21:32
---
6F：推 Skyblueway: 钱 203.217.122.40 03/14 21:32
7F：推 Himiko9975: 阿钱ㄋ 36.234.37.1 03/14 21:32
8F：推 peter2010112: 钱 101.12.47.204 03/14 21:33
9F：推 ROCKSAGA: 钱 219.68.44.166 03/14 21:33
---
10F：推 mottohayaku: 140.109.16.77 03/14 21:33
---
11F：推 d9633368: 钱 1.200.246.121 03/14 21:33
12F：推 trumpet999: 推 180.217.216.79 03/14 21:34
13F：推 fvx335: 推 180.217.129.57 03/14 21:34
14F：→ fvx335: 推 180.217.129.57 03/14 21:34
15F：→ fvx335: 推 180.217.129.57 03/14 21:35
16F：推 sense520: 推 110.28.137.129 03/14 21:35
---
17F：推 wei8988: 推 101.10.6.212 03/14 21:35
---
18F：推 zerhbbo78: 好 61.230.98.205 03/14 21:35
19F：推 alba5188: 推 125.229.71.173 03/14 21:35
20F：嘘 enthpzd: 我偏要嘘，推的是脑袋有洞吗 101.137.70.221 03/14 21:35
21F：推 brother001: 钱 114.46.160.118 03/14 21:35
22F：推 lwt501cx: 钱 222.157.97.188 03/14 21:35
---
23F：推 kyosukeakiba: 哇赛！现在抢钱程式还能算准几楼才 114.44.134.162 03/14 21:35
---
24F：推 exarawdon: 推 220.136.136.41 03/14 21:35
25F：→ kyosukeakiba: 推文耶！厉害了！ 114.44.134.162 03/14 21:35
26F：推 Yehei: 钱钱，谢谢 1.172.171.217 03/14 21:35
27F：推 ajoe789g2000: 钱 39.12.138.31 03/14 21:35
28F：→ dofine: 推 114.32.191.53 03/14 21:35
29F：推 patoosun: 钱 111.71.96.27 03/14 21:36
---
30F：推 lwt501cx: 发钱的程式可以设定阿 222.157.97.188 03/14 21:36
---
31F：推 AKboyjeff: 推 223.139.16.87 03/14 21:36
32F：推 thegreatlcx: 钱啦 干 101.10.0.155 03/14 21:36
33F：推 tiger4friend: 推 101.3.124.147 03/14 21:37
34F：嘘 dbdudsorj: 抽菸仔真的锲而不舍馁 111.249.134.62 03/14 21:38
35F：推 wertes: 推223.136.193.197 03/14 21:38
---
36F：推 wait0315: 钱! 111.251.75.246 03/14 21:39
---
37F：推 taroman: 钱 49.216.223.104 03/14 21:39
38F：推 kaodio: % 118.160.107.29 03/14 21:39
39F：推 coffee112: 钱 218.164.144.56 03/14 21:39
40F：推 abcrr123: 好 223.138.39.240 03/14 21:40
---
41F：推 CalmEarth: 推 223.137.228.91 03/14 21:40
---
42F：推 SillyCon: 推223.141.176.178 03/14 21:41
43F：推 weian18663: 钱123.192.200.127 03/14 21:41
44F：推 brazil: ok 36.227.41.33 03/14 21:42
45F：推 awe1030: 钱 114.44.18.46 03/14 21:44
---
46F：推 changarm: 钱111.249.227.220 03/14 21:44
---
47F：嘘 k44754: 可黏 180.217.151.31 03/14 21:44
48F：推 echyerrr: 钱 223.137.79.69 03/14 21:44
49F：→ dot0911: 钱 27.242.193.143 03/14 21:45
50F：推 ggsize123: 钱122.121.200.215 03/14 21:46
51F：推 lin1020: 推116.241.208.105 03/14 21:47
52F：推 minJohnny: n 61.62.148.70 03/14 21:47
53F：→ pornpig32: 钱 27.53.113.91 03/14 21:48
54F：→ pornpig32: 钱 27.53.113.91 03/14 21:48
55F：→ pornpig32: 给我钱啦 27.53.113.91 03/14 21:48
56F：→ pornpig32: 钱呢 27.53.113.91 03/14 21:48
---
58F：推 saint01: 好 111.253.2.161 03/14 21:49
---
59F：→ dreamyello: 加油 灭绝吸烟族群 111.71.13.39 03/14 21:49
60F：推 darkuso: 推 114.40.67.149 03/14 21:49
61F：推 darkarea: 钱 1.175.153.57 03/14 21:49
62F：推 yenmingchen: 钱 175.182.208.69 03/14 21:50
63F：嘘 wsdykssj: 死菸鬼看一次嘘一次 119.14.85.132 03/14 21:51
---
64F：推 steward68: 钱 123.205.155.68 03/14 21:51
---
65F：嘘 BaDoYao: 滚 1.170.214.61 03/14 21:54
66F：推 komengtu: $ 1.170.201.95 03/14 21:55
67F：推 zealotlai274: 推 1.164.118.185 03/14 21:59
68F：嘘 sincere77: 好了啦，商人利益到底关ptt什麽事 60.154.118.126 03/14 21:59
69F：推 missian: 推 36.235.194.229 03/14 22:02
70F：推 cute8: 钱 36.230.135.247 03/14 22:03
---
71F：推 peter2010112: 推 101.12.47.204 03/14 22:04
---
72F：→ InoueNagi: 钱114.136.200.196 03/14 22:06
73F：推 Detonate: 钱 49.159.250.139 03/14 22:06
74F：推 InoueNagi: 钱114.136.200.196 03/14 22:06
75F：推 xcola: 推 180.218.93.36 03/14 22:06
76F：→ Detonate: 我要钱啦 49.159.250.139 03/14 22:07
77F：→ Detonate: 推推推给我钱 49.159.250.139 03/14 22:07
78F：→ Detonate: 钱 49.159.250.139 03/14 22:07
79F：→ Detonate: 钱 49.159.250.139 03/14 22:08
80F：→ Detonate: 钱 49.159.250.139 03/14 22:08
81F：推 Forty41One: 钱 61.230.80.60 03/14 22:09
---
82F：推 InoueNagi: 钱114.136.200.196 03/14 22:09
---
83F：推 InoueNagi: 钱114.136.200.196 03/14 22:09
84F：推 gigfsijk: 钱 111.83.54.157 03/14 22:11
85F：推 a826451115: 推 211.76.58.170 03/14 22:12
86F：推 twinxxxx: 推223.138.128.126 03/14 22:14
---
87F：推 nick2xxxx: 推223.138.128.126 03/14 22:14
---
88F：推 inhumanq: 推123.193.249.122 03/14 22:14
89F：推 Ayanami5566: 钱 36.226.100.243 03/14 22:15
90F：推 krsone: 新北ok 绿色狗杂种会帮101.137.124.250 03/14 22:15
91F：推 freehand1122: 推220.141.129.128 03/14 22:15
---
92F：推 bucawang: 推 36.226.67.136 03/14 22:17
---
93F：推 TWSE2330: 推 1.168.242.9 03/14 22:21
94F：→ dosoleil: 缓解烟瘾 减低燃烟危害？ 223.139.158.94 03/14 22:25
95F：推 tw00053142: 钱钱 36.226.178.121 03/14 22:26
96F：推 kq1816: 钱 111.83.200.54 03/14 22:28
97F：推 lahiboy: 钱钱220.136.214.251 03/14 22:28
---
98F：推 ycsheaven: 钱 114.46.213.60 03/14 22:32
---
99F：推 NDSLite: 0 111.82.171.255 03/14 22:33
100F：推 swimming5445: 推 42.77.47.220 03/14 22:33
101F：推 linda17a3: 好 1.200.132.150 03/14 22:34
102F：推 wilson31507: 钱223.137.255.171 03/14 22:35
---
103F：推 kklong0330: 钱 1.200.247.143 03/14 22:42
---
104F：推 CingChenH: $$$ 58.114.155.185 03/14 22:44
105F：嘘 mynewid: 有医疗用大麻菸弹我给过 101.12.44.102 03/14 22:47
106F：推 AKZA: 推 36.229.199.40 03/14 22:47
107F：推 asd10733: 推 27.51.32.72 03/14 22:49
108F：推 david840628: 推 101.10.11.191 03/14 23:00
---
109F：推 hsiao15165: 好111.251.167.181 03/14 23:02
---
110F：推 icedata: 这就电子烟商危害纸菸商的利益 1.200.150.6 03/14 23:03
111F：推 daccdacc: 钱 1.200.73.7 03/14 23:09
112F：推 oldli0605: 推 1.34.115.63 03/14 23:20
113F：推 hhi80482: 钱 125.224.22.218 03/14 23:42
114F：→ chshaur: $$$ 218.161.101.27 03/14 23:43
---
115F：推 rayjean: 推 61.227.39.26 03/14 23:56
---
116F：推 skykoc: 推114.136.130.189 03/14 23:56
117F：推 lucieph: 推 61.227.39.26 03/14 23:57
118F：推 akiranon: 钱 101.9.198.46 03/15 00:09
119F：推 gmisnotme: 推 给钱 1.175.149.64 03/15 00:11
---
120F：推 m9315030: 前 114.34.86.171 03/15 00:20
---
121F：推 takemyarms: 推 61.70.27.47 03/15 00:23
122F：推 wade11293: 钱 1.171.213.81 03/15 00:29
123F：推 elainechain: 推 36.225.105.40 03/15 00:32
124F：推 lindow168: 推 114.39.203.189 03/15 00:32
---
125F：推 Cookieptt: $ 114.38.18.203 03/15 00:48
---
126F：推 zhicong: ＄ 27.51.112.199 03/15 00:50
127F：→ yuetako: 钱 42.77.13.85 03/15 01:48
128F：推 adminc: 推 114.43.164.12 03/15 01:49
129F：推 archdaily: 推 223.137.167.32 03/15 01:53
※ 编辑: tobetwob (1.200.76.162 台湾), 03/15/2024 02:00:52
130F：推 dennis7653: 推你 还在太好了 203.204.3.105 03/15 02:02
近期我得开集资了，2017吵到现在2024，我个人已经烧了上百万，没钱了。
加热菸具变医疗器材! 王郁扬酸:抽加热菸有疗效?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aS7G7TpG29w
---
131F：推 Bonkon: 这个要推 114.37.4.197 03/15 02:16
---
楼上标注帐号已发钱，谢谢大家，下次见。
※ 编辑: tobetwob (1.200.76.162 台湾), 03/15/2024 02:37:41
132F：推 leterg: 原来加热烟有疗效 1.200.137.129 03/15 03:14
133F：推 lavitar: 钱 120.110.170.36 03/15 06:18
134F：推 JAYOAOA: + 114.40.140.134 03/15 06:45
135F：推 abcte: 好 61.230.78.209 03/15 06:58
---
136F：推 tmgg: 推 42.79.238.155 03/15 07:32
---
137F：推 p3: $ 61.222.158.103 03/15 07:42
138F：推 windwater14: 长知识 推 42.72.49.84 03/15 09:19
139F：推 my852626: 钱 140.112.24.192 03/15 10:17
140F：→ yang5115: 钱 1.200.177.45 03/15 10:38
141F：推 elvis007: $ 39.12.42.53 03/15 11:19
---
142F：推 wargods8402: 可以疗癒身心 这样行吗？ 61.230.251.183 03/15 11:43
---
143F：→ vasia: 避孕吧，调节生育126.175.239.176 03/15 11:51
144F：推 GoodTao: 钱 42.71.108.1 03/15 12:24
以上标注帐号已发钱。
※ 编辑: tobetwob (1.200.76.162 台湾), 03/15/2024 13:16:25
145F：推 Beckhan: 钱 223.138.7.50 03/15 14:42
146F：推 channel79: 钱 111.71.26.67 03/15 15:47
147F：嘘 smallcar801: 抽烟不好关政府屁事，你可以强迫抽122.116.143.126 03/15 17:25
148F：→ smallcar801: 烟的人拿烟捐去强制保险，抽烟相关122.116.143.126 03/15 17:25
149F：→ smallcar801: 疾病不能使用健保啊，看到左派政府122.116.143.126 03/15 17:25
150F：→ smallcar801: 就觉得恶心，更恶心的是那些被政府122.116.143.126 03/15 17:25
151F：→ smallcar801: 莫名其妙的剥夺自由还要帮政府护航122.116.143.126 03/15 17:25
152F：→ smallcar801: 的恶心底层觉青122.116.143.126 03/15 17:25
153F：推 takenaka0208: 推 180.217.32.148 03/15 18:59
154F：→ vev: 钱 49.216.18.33 03/16 22:01
155F：推 boudin: 政府如此这般，何不禁醣，後果不比菸少。 61.219.178.212 03/19 11:56