作者freemind99 (freemind99)
看板GMAT
标题[语文] gwd-cr 25-2
时间Sun Dec 7 20:18:05 2008
2. GWD25-Q2.
In two months, the legal minimum wage in the country of Kirlandia will
increase from five Kirlandic dollars(KD5.00) Per hour to KD5.50 per hour.
Opponents of this increase have argued that the resulting rise in wages will
drive the inflation rate up. In fact its impact on wages will probably be
negligible, since only a very small proportion of all Kirfandic workers are
currently receiving less than KD5.50 per hour.
Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
A. Most people in Kirlandia who are currently earning the minimum wage
have been employed at their current jobs for less than a year.
B. Some firms in Kirlandia have paid workers considerably less than KD5.00
per hour, in violation of Kirlandic employment regulations.
C. Many businesses hire trainees at or near the minimum wage but must
reward trained workers by keeping their pay levels above the pay level
of trainees.
D. The greatest growth in Kirlandia’s economy in recent years has been
in those sectors where workers earn wages that tend to be much higher
than the minimum wage.
E. The current minimum wage is insufficient for a worker holding only one
job to earn enough to support a family, even when working full time at
that job.
这题之前在来欣上课时谢老师说是B
不过我看CD上讨论多半prefer C
我也觉得C比较好
因为B感觉很怪 原题目说只有一小部分人是低於KD5.50
但B却又说有些公司付给员工低於KD5.50
好像直接推翻掉原题目给的premise
总觉得应该像C一样找其他原因来反驳才是
想跟大家讨论看看到底哪个答案比较好?
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 123.193.145.194
1F:推 Vinicks:我来说一下喔 我觉得(B)答案那个some就否定了许多可能 12/07 21:56
2F:→ Vinicks:因为some这个字意思太广 另外不能保证法律制定下去後 12/07 21:57
3F:→ Vinicks:这些违反最低薪资的公司会去遵守 (C)的话就是说现在许多 12/07 21:58
4F:→ Vinicks:公司 要去留住训练好的员工的话 就要付给比训练中员工 12/07 21:58
5F:→ Vinicks:更高的薪水 关键来了 这些训练中员工刚好薪资等於最低薪资 12/07 21:59
6F:→ Vinicks:因此5.0是最低薪资 而5.5如果现在变最低薪资的话 那表示 12/07 22:01
7F:→ Vinicks:训练好的员工 薪资会大於5.5以上 12/07 22:05
8F:→ Vinicks:因此反驳 但是我觉得 反驳力道不强 但是已经是五个最好的 12/07 22:07
9F:→ Vinicks:我觉得力道不强是因为 他没有说员工多寡 只有说很多公司 12/07 22:07
10F:→ Vinicks:大家一起讨论看看呗 12/07 22:08
11F:→ Vinicks:但也有可能是很多公司就隐含很多员工的意思 那就可以反驳 12/07 22:09
12F:→ Vinicks:(C)是最好的答案 如果说many company等同於很多员工的话 12/07 22:10
13F:→ Vinicks:这样就能反驳那些反对的人说small proportion噜~~ 12/07 22:10