作者libys (libys)
看板GMAT
标题[语文] GWD-TN-20 Q17
时间Wed Aug 6 16:55:36 2008
TN20-17 (GWD30-Q17)
By the same techniques used for genetically enhancing plants, making them
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
disease- or pest-resistant, researchers have been able to increase the amount
of protein in potatoes, sweet potatoes, and tobacco.
A)By the same techniques used for genetically enhancing plants,making them
B)With the same techniques to genetically enhance plants, so that they are
C)Employing the same techniques used to genetically enhance plants so that they
are
D)Employing the same techniques to genetically enhance plants, which makes them
E)Employing the same techniques for genetically enhancing plants that make them
答案不确定是哪一个，
TN的答案是B，ChaseDream上蛮多讨论说是E，两年多前补习时老师说是D
想请大家一起来讨论，谢谢。
列出ChaseDream上的部分讨论内容
C) employ 和 use 的意思重复，so that用法奇怪
D) which和them的指代问题，ChaseDream上说意思很不清楚，但是补习班老师说非限定用
法的关系代名词指前一句话，在这里which是指Employing....plants，而them是指
plants
E) 补习班老师说应该用to engance，但是ChaseDream上认为for enhancing限定性修释
techniques，在这里比to enhance好，而that是指techniques
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 218.167.99.132
1F：→ jennes:同意(D),(B)与(C)的they指代不清 08/06 17:02
2F：→ jennes:(E)that关代修饰plant,改变句意 08/06 17:03
3F：→ jennes:以上个人意见请参考，若有错误欢迎指正噜 08/06 17:04
4F：推 patricia331:可是 (D)which很少可以指代一整个句子的吧? 08/06 17:15
5F：→ jennes:有挖 OG#43 which 指一整件事喔(只是题目把which改成分词) 08/06 17:23
6F：推 patricia331:J大说的是 bringing那题嘛? 08/06 17:34
7F：→ jennes:是阿 不过gmat中which以非限定用法修饰句子的还真少 08/06 17:53
8F：推 patricia331:我觉得那题不是用which改成分词耶 是用伴随副词的概念 08/06 18:25
9F：→ jennes:若当伴随副词，bringing主词变成five fledging sea eagles 08/06 18:37
10F：→ jennes:整句话的意思就会变得很奇怪喔 小海鸥不会带回34只成鸟阿~ 08/06 18:38
11F：→ jennes:这样句意就会很奇怪, 因为小海鸥不会带回34只成鸟阿~~ 08/06 18:39
12F：→ jennes:而且当伴随副,选项(E)就可以选噜..但OG解释,主词不合逻辑 08/06 18:49
13F：推 patricia331:谢谢J大 08/06 20:20