作者Waitingchen (Rejoyce )
看板Ecophilia
标题Re: 绿色电子产品排行：任天堂垫底 三星东芝列第一
时间Mon Mar 24 08:45:08 2008
补充一下，绿色和平的完整报告网址：
http://www.greenpeace.org/international/campaigns/toxics/electronics/
how-the-companies-line-up
（缩址：
http://tinyurl.com/cc4j9）
我自己是觉得这份报告做的很用心，
网页上有每个厂牌的单独报告，从图表可以很清楚看到分数是怎麽来的
（不过要先花点时间看说明就是了）
另一个重要的资讯是每次报告排名的变化，
如果一直稳定往前，
那该企业想要走环保路线的企图就比较明显。
18个厂牌的分数排序是
7.7 Samsung - Scores well on toxic chemicals policy.
Loses points for incomplete takeback practice.
7.7 Toshiba - Continued improvement, especially on e-waste and
recycling policy.
7.3 Nokia - Strong on toxic chemicals elimination but penalty
point for deficiencies in takeback practice remains.
7.3 Sony - More products free of toxic PVC and improved reporting
on recycling and takeback especially in the US.
7.3 Dell - Unchanged since the last version, still no products on
the market without the worst chemicals.
7.3 Lenovo - Unchanged since the last version, still no products
on the market without the worst chemicals.
6.7 Sony Ericsson - Drops 6 places due to losing points on its
e-waste policy and practice.
6.7 LGE -Dropping 2 places, loses point on recycling reporting.
6.7 Apple - Steady rise, new models reducing the use of toxic
chemicals, takeback programme still needs to be global.
6.7 Fujitsu-Siemens - Dropping down, needs toxic elimination timelines
and better reporting of amounts recycled.
6.7 HP - Timeline for eliminating worst toxic chemicals, though not for
all products; needs to improve takeback coverage.
6.3 Motorola - Penalty point for poor takeback practice lifted.
Still no timeline for eliminating the most toxic chemicals.
5.7 Acer - Dropping down. Still no products on the market without
the worst chemicals and needs better takeback coverage
and reporting of amounts recycled.
5 Sharp - Some plus points on toxic chemicals elimination and
slight improvement on takeback policy and practice.
4.7 Panasonic - New to the guide - some plus points on toxic chemicals
elimination but poor takeback policy and practice.
4.7 Microsoft -Improved timeline for toxic chemicals elimination (2010)
but poor takeback policy and practice.
4.3 Philips - Improved toxic chemicals elimination deadline but zero
points on e-waste recycling.
0.3 Nintendo - Tiny improvement but still way behind.
---
反正前五名大概都可说是环保品牌，
最後那几个不到五分的就请避免购买，
特别是任天堂....不到一分是怎样.....Orz
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 69.234.149.150
1F：→ freeunixer:台湾的 ASUS 连上榜都没有 XD 03/24 09:17
2F：推 BarkingSin:其实我觉得环不环保和耐用性真的有关系…←也看使用者 03/24 09:18
3F：→ BarkingSin:假如一个产品好用/耐用到很久都不想/不用换 03/24 09:20
4F：→ BarkingSin:其实最後的环境负担不见得是对厂商的评比可以看出来的 03/24 09:20
5F：→ BarkingSin:当然还是对任天堂的分数很orz…Wii…(远目) 03/24 09:22
6F：→ Waitingchen:耐用性有算在评分里面呀，另外还有毒物、回收等 03/24 12:19
7F：推 hunggg:Sony分数比上次进步很多 03/24 12:51