作者TKB5566 (= =)
看板DummyHistory
标题[讨论] 尼古拉二世的儿女,有可能成功逃出俄国?
时间Sat Jul 29 19:42:05 2023
刚刚在维基百科看尼古拉二世的条目,看到他有一子四女,接着我随手点进去
其中一个女儿的条目:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Duchess_Tatiana_Nikolaevna_of_Russia
......天啊也太正了吧~~~~~
然後我又看到该条目以下的介绍:
Like her sisters,
Tatiana was unworldly and naive. When she was young, she
was shocked to learn that her governess Margaretta Eagar was paid for taking
care of her. When Eagar told her that "you have seen me get my money every
month,"
Tatiana replied that "I always thought it was a present to you."[27]
When her lady-in-waiting sent a carriage without an attendant, Tatiana and
Olga decided to go shopping for the first time. They ordered the carriage to
stop near a group of shops and went into one of the stores. The shopkeepers
did not recognize them because they wore nurses' uniforms.
They left the shop
without buying anything, because they didn't carry money with them and had no
idea how to use it. The next day, they asked Chebotareva how to use money.
一段是她不知道原来工作会有薪水;另一段是她不知道钱要怎麽使用。
另一个女儿的条目:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Duchess_Olga_Nikolaevna_of_Russia
Due to her sheltered life, Olga had little experience with the world. She and
her sisters had little understanding of money, because they had not had an
opportunity to shop in stores or to see money exchange hands.
Young Olga once
thought that a hat maker who came to the palace had given her a new hat as a
present.
Olga was once frightened when she witnessed a policeman arresting someone on
the street.
She thought the policeman would come to arrest her because she
had behaved badly for Miss Eagar.
When reading a history lesson, she remarked that
she was glad she lived in
current times, when people were good and not as evil as they had been in the
past.
一段是她以为前来为她工作的帽匠是想要送她帽子当礼物;
下一段是她以为她会因对旁人不好被警察抓;最後一段是她以为当今社会大家都是好人。
......长的这麽漂亮、个性好又爱照顾人又不黯世事到难以想像的女孩们,
即使是放到现在,也会是众多男人想要好好保护的对象。
而根据维基条目的记载,
1917年俄国革命当下,这些女孩们确实也感受到了革命者对她们的威胁,觉得很不舒服。
原本尼古拉二世希望带着他的家人逃往英国,但被英王乔治五世拒绝了。
但是英王之所以会拒绝,是因为尼古拉二世跟皇后的名声实在太糟,并非这些女孩的错。
--------------------------------------------
那麽,在当时的环境之下,这些女孩们有办法或有可能成功逃离俄国,
使其免於遭受俄共的屠杀吗?
1917年当下,上面条目提到的两位尼古拉二世的女儿:奥尔加跟塔季扬娜,
都年过20岁,在当时都是已经可以嫁人的年纪。而且根据记载,有为数不少的
欧洲王室成员喜爱她们,希望和她们通婚。那这样的话,当时尼古拉二世的女儿们,
有可能藉由跟他国王室通婚,藉机逃离俄国,免於遭受俄共虐杀?
抑或是俄国皇室在国外的支持者,有可能在十月革命俄共掌权前,
同较为温和的临时政府谈判,将她们营救出来吗?
又或是有其他较清醒的王室成员,赶在兵士们叛变、封锁皇室一家住所之前组织行动,
将她们带出俄国?并以儿童(这时应该要叫young lady,但为了宣传方便。就称为儿童)
是无辜的无害的名义,说服较有人权观念的欧洲国家收留?
大家觉得呢?
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc), 来自: 1.167.40.21 (台湾)
※ 文章网址: https://webptt.com/cn.aspx?n=bbs/DummyHistory/M.1690630927.A.27C.html
1F:推 moslaa: 恩恩 以前八卦板,我记得是八卦板吧,有某乡民对末代沙皇 07/29 21:23
2F:→ moslaa: 的女儿们满熟的,有一次或两次,搭配多张女儿们的历史照片 07/29 21:24
3F:→ moslaa: 做介绍。看完後,真觉得1. 漂亮可爱又活泼 2. 遗憾都被杀 07/29 21:25
4F:推 chewie: 早点嫁出去比较有可能 但可惜DNA都确定已经罹难了 07/30 08:10
5F:→ chewie: 另外也不必什麽说服 英王室肯定收留 俄皇后的外祖母是维多 07/30 08:15
6F:→ chewie: 利亚女王啊XD 07/30 08:15
7F:推 sanae0307: 其实偷偷去德国,威廉二世应该愿意当作亲女儿收养 07/30 11:07
8F:推 yukiss: 迪士尼收购FOX之後会怎麽重拍《真假公主安娜塔西亚》? 07/30 19:17
9F:推 Segal: 沙皇夫妇都是白的可是女主角是黑的 07/31 13:30
10F:→ Segal: 即使如此世人依旧双眼迷离,安能辨真假? 07/31 13:30
11F:→ kiranagisa: 背景音乐传来萧煌奇的歌声 08/01 13:58
12F:→ LaurenceS: 普 08/01 20:49
13F:推 MarchelKaton: 其实还是因为犹豫不决和轻信俄共不会动手才导致祸 08/12 00:30
14F:→ MarchelKaton: 害己身 08/12 00:31
15F:→ MarchelKaton: 罗曼诺夫家族和一些贵族也是有跑得快的就没事 08/12 00:31