作者peachlai (小桃)
看板Contacts
标题[心得] 6个厂牌散光抛的试戴心得与比较
时间Fri May 30 10:40:41 2008
有图片和加强重点的网志版
http://www.wretch.cc/blog/peachlai/13470865
=====================
落落长文字版:
真不知道该说是幸运还是不幸
早在2月的时候,小桃就去学校的诊所挂眼科
想要配抛弃式的散光隐形眼镜
但是第一次在美国要配隐形眼镜,是一定要花钱买fitting plan的
光量量视力是不够的,一定要亲自试戴到满意为止
因为散光片比较贵,而且要注意的又比较多,所以fitting plan花了我75块美金
竟然花了这麽一大笔钱,小桃本来想要能戴的都戴,把各个牌子都试试看
不过目前花了三个多月的时间还在试,小桃已经失去耐心
(厂商订货要等两个礼拜,试戴又要一个礼拜)
在试了以下众多牌子後,小桃终於决定要订哪一副了
以下就来介绍小桃配戴各家散光抛的心得吧
1. Cooper Vision出的月抛Proclear Toric
http://www.contactlensking.com/procleartoric.aspx
Lens Type:
Monthly replacement disposable soft contact lenses
Package Details:
6 daily wear tinted soft contact lenses in buffered 0.9% saline.
Material and % of content: 38% omafilcon A
Water % of content: 62%
Manufacturer:
CooperVision
Irvine, CA
因为我跟医生说我戴隐形眼镜有乾眼的现象
所以医生就推荐我proclear
说这个proclear专对乾眼正,使用了新的材质
应该可以减轻我乾眼的不舒服
一开始我是戴8.4的基弧,可是这个弧度让我的眼睛很不舒服
有种被隐形眼镜紧抓的感觉
所以隔了一个礼拜又试了8.8的基弧
不过佩戴散光片的人应该要有个认知
就是基弧数目愈大,镜片旋转的可能性就越高
镜片旋转得越厉害,刻度就越容易跑掉,会有视力不稳定的情况
有时候清楚,有时候模糊这样
所以虽然8.8有比较舒服了,但是还满容易让我视力模糊
而且proclear的新材质对我没什麽效用,戴久了依然觉得眼睛很乾
2. 博视伦的双周抛舒服能Soflens 66散光片
http://www.lens.com/contact-lenses/lens127.asp
SofLens Toric (SofLens 66 Toric) is a two-week replacement lens for people with astigmatism. The SofLens Toric (SofLens 66 Toric) contact lens has a unique design that is exceptionally easy to wear. It provides clear vision, and exceptional comfort consistently from lens to lens. After two weeks, throw your lenses away and start over with a fresh pair.
Accurate fit Exceptional comfort because they're 66% water Visibility tint for easy handling
Lens Type:
1-2 week disposable soft contact lenses for astigmatism
Package Details:
6 lenses immersed in buffered saline solution.
Material and % of content: 34% polymer (alphafilcon A)
Water % of content: 66%
Manufacturer:
Bausch & Lomb
Rochester, NY
博视伦的舒服能双周抛散光片在市面上已经满久了
受到的评价也很不错
医生推荐给我,是因为很多人都觉得这款很舒服
虽然基弧8.5对我来说稍稍有点紧紧的
不过也因为这样,镜片旋转得不多,视力一直保持在很清楚的状态
镜片很薄,戴着几乎没有存在感
其实小桃颇为满意
无奈,戴了6个小时以後,就会开始觉得眼睛很乾
所以虽然觉得挺不错的了,小桃还是想试试看其他牌子
3. 博视伦纯视月抛散光片PureVision
http://www.lens.com/contact-lenses/lens413.asp
Lens Type:
This lens is designed to be worn as an extended wear lens for up to 30 days of continuous wear. However, only your eye care provider can determine if these lenses are right for you and how many days and nights you can wear them. It is important that you follow your eye care provider's wearing instructions.
Package Details:
6 lenses immersed in buffered saline solution
Material and % of content: 64% polymer (Balafilcon A)
Water % of content: 36%
Manufacturer:
Bausch & Lomb
Rochester, NY
博视伦的纯视注明的是他的高透氧率
毕竟戴隐形眼镜最大的问题,就是角膜缺氧
在所有散光抛中,纯视应该是透氧率最高的,对眼睛似乎也最好
况且如果光看数据,博士伦的基弧8.7,不会太紧又不会太松
含水量36%颇低,可能比较不会乾眼
评估起来是很理想的一副眼镜
可是呢~~~~小桃试戴起来
只能用一整个不舒服来形容(多亏纯视还是我特地请医院帮我订的)
异物感明显就不说了,在我眼睛上
不但不湿润,而且一开始就挺乾燥
更惨的是,模糊的时间比清楚的时间多
只能说,小桃跟纯视是绝对的犯冲
4. 娇生的双周抛超水感散光片
http://www.lens.com/contact-lenses/lens403.asp
HYDRACLEARTM is a remarkable moisture rich element that lies throughout the interior and exterior of the ACUVUER ADVANCETM for Astigmatism contact lens creating a unique soft, silky feel. ACUVUER ADVANCETM with HYDRACLEARTM... A NEW CATEGORY OF CONTACT LENSES
Low dehydration
Soft and flexible material
Highest UVA and UVB Blocking
Low protein deposits
Features Accelerated Stabilization Design – gives astigmatic patients crisp, clear, stable vision.
Lens Type:
1-2 week disposable soft contact lenses for astigmatism
Package Details:
6 visibly tinted UV blocking lenses immersed in buffered saline solution
Material and % of content: 53% polymer (galyfilcon A)
Water % of content: 47%
Other info:
These contacts are not designed to change eye color. The tint is designed to facilitate locating the contacts in solution.
These contacts also contain a vertical indicator to help ensure proper application.
Manufacturer:
Johnson and Johnson Vision Products, Inc.
Jacksonville, FL
这款台湾好像没有,小桃只能说台湾没有,真是太可惜了!!
先来说说我一开始对娇生超水感的印象吧
其实这一副是我众多试戴的眼镜中,唯一的现货(完全不用等)
眼科技师直接从诊所的库存拿给我佩戴
刚戴上去的时候,小桃没有特别感觉
因为跟博视伦的舒服能差不多舒服,而且基弧8.6(其实最和我的眼型)
比舒服能稍微会旋转,一开始有比较模糊一些
本来戴了以後暗暗决定,就选舒服能吧
两者虽然一样舒服,不过舒服能的清晰度有比较稳定...
不过呢!!!这个周末因为参加学姊的婚礼,隐形眼镜一整天戴下来超过14个小时
才发现娇生超水感的可贵
不乾!!真的不乾耶~~~越戴越不乾,越没有存在感
小桃真是感动得不得了
戴隐形眼镜已经超过10年了,第一次体验到8个小时以後也不乾的境界
於是,舒服能跟超水感打擂台後的结果
小桃决定选择娇生超水感
=============================
加了一个分隔线在这边,是因为以下这两个牌子,不是这次fitting plan戴的
而是以前在美国没有硬性规定要处方签的时代
小桃就在网路上自己挑来戴的
5. 视康的月抛风格式Focus
http://www.lens.com/contact-lenses/lens152.asp
Focus Toric contact lenses are a leading soft contact lens for astigmatism available in a wide range of prescriptions to fit a variety of vision correction needs. Focus Toric is designed as a monthly replacement lens.
Lens Type:
Monthly disposable soft contact lens for astigmatism
Package Details:
6 lenses immersed in buffered saline solution
Material and % of content: 45% polymer (vifilcon A)
Water % of content: 55%
Manufacturer:
CIBA Vision Corp.
Duluth, GA
视康的Focus小桃以前戴了好一阵子
因为基弧有出到8.9,所以小桃觉得不会有眼睛被紧抓的感觉
不过也因为基弧8.9,所以选转得满厉害的,视力常常不清楚
而且也没有特别保湿
那时候戴了一年多,就决定还是换回年抛的长戴式散光片
因为Focus实在很容易让我乾眼
一乾就整个模糊不清楚了
而且现在回想起来,舒适度也没有舒服能和超涵水高
6. 视康的双周抛Freshlook(我不知道中文名是啥~~)
http://www.1800contacts.com/lens/freshlook-toric.htm
Think you can't wear soft contact lenses because you have astigmatism? That's the way it used to be, but not any more. Designed especially for correcting astigmatism, toric soft contact lenses can give you the same vision clarity you enjoyed while wearing glasses.
Freshlook Toric contact lenses are designed as a 1-2 week disposable, soft contact lens for astigmatism. FreshLook Toric contact lenses are tinted green with the color additive phthalocyanine green for easy visibility for handling.
Lens Type:
1-2 week disposable soft contact lenses for astigmatism
Package Details:
6 visibly tinted contact lenses immersed in buffered saline solution.
Material and % of content: 45% polymer (phenfilcon A)
Water % of content: 55%
Manufacturer:
CIBA Vision Corp.
Duluth, GA
我猜这个Freshlook应该是早期的散光抛
功能非常的基本,没有什麽特别的(从介绍词就知道)
这是我第一副自己乱订的隐形眼镜
基弧8.4,实在是太紧了!戴了一次就不想在戴
所以马上被打入冷宫,没什麽特别感言
最後来比较这几个厂牌戴起来的感觉
1. 刚戴上眼的舒适度
博视伦舒服能 = 娇生超水感 > Cooper Proclear = 视康风格式 > 视康 Freshlook > 博视伦纯视
2. 戴数个小时以後的舒适度
娇生超水感 > 博士伦舒服能 = Cooper Proclear > 视康风格式 > 视康 Freshlook > 博视伦纯视
3. 视力清晰度
博视伦舒服能 > 娇生超水感 > Cooper Proclear = 视康风格式 > 视康 Freshlook > 博视伦纯视
4. 价格 (以每月双眼要花的钱来计算)
视康 Freshlook (美金33) > 娇生超水感 ($20) > Cooper Proclear ($14) > 博视伦舒服能 = 博视伦纯视 =视康风格式 ($13)
小桃试的这几个牌子不是双周抛就是月抛
因为小桃的散光225度,日抛都没做到这个度数
所以眼科技师就不让小桃试了
戴了这麽多,能选到一个适合自己的很开心
很可惜台湾没有出娇生超水感的散光
不然小桃非常推荐呢!!
台湾有舒服能,舒服能其实表现的也很好
就是到戴久了会比较乾~~~
不然也是很不错的选择
希望这个心得分享对想买散光抛的朋友有帮助*^_______^*
--
我是素宝宝*^O^*
http://www.wretch.cc/blog/peachlai
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 68.252.43.175
※ 编辑: peachlai 来自: 68.252.43.175 (05/30 11:23)
1F:推 jimyang0422:台湾闪光目前好像就是博士伦双周抛 125.228.236.86 05/30 11:28
2F:→ jimyang0422:娇生和视康有出闪光日抛 125.228.236.86 05/30 11:29
3F:→ jimyang0422:还有博士伦的纯视闪光 125.228.236.86 05/30 11:30
4F:→ jimyang0422:布过我也是有乾眼现象~~只有娇生比较 125.228.236.86 05/30 11:31
5F:→ jimyang0422:舒服些~~感谢大大的分享^^ 125.228.236.86 05/30 11:31
6F:推 gargoyle:台湾有出2,3,5 没有4真是太可惜了~ 140.118.196.6 05/30 11:47
7F:→ u7273:是小桃耶~hello 61.227.80.96 06/01 04:27