延续#1RUOXdna推文处tf建议的「反律主义」探讨： 这篇摘要介绍了那时路德处理的争论，比较好懂一点 https://lutheranreformation.org/history/the-antinomian-disputations/ 有些句子我真的看到板上两造辩论的影子！ "Agricola and the Antinomians did not deny the presence of sin in the life of the Christian. However, they saw the Law as a dead letter, which by no means could bring about repentance. Repentance is brought about by the work of the Holy Spirit, as Jesus teaches in John 14-16, and the antinomians operated with the idea that the Holy Spirit did not work through the Law. Instead, they believed that the Holy Spirit operates only in the Gospel. Therefore, the preaching of the crucified Christ alone would lead to true repentance. Repentance from sin was not about recognizing that one had violated the Law but that one had done harm to the Son of Man, who laid down His life for the salvation of sinners." 这段对反律主义论点的描绘，跟板上会所弟兄表述的几乎一致。 并非罪大恶极，甚至颇有说服力，但就是怪怪的。 至於路德怎麽回应？ "For Luther, if one would lose the proclamation of the Law, one would also lose the sweet gospel which sets sinners free from condemnation. He said, “ Yet it is safest to turn to a middle road, to turn too much neither to the right nor to the left. For both are dangerous, and, as I said already, for this reason also, the office of the word was instituted, that we might teach both, that is, the Law and the Gospel. The one cannot properly be taught or dealt with safely without the other…So here too one must divide well, lest only one part be taught in the churches—either fear and sorrow or consolation and joy—but both at the same time.”[4] Both Law and Gospel are necessary for repentance: the Law which works contrition (sorrow for sin) and the Gospel which works faith in the promise of forgiveness. Is there a need for the preaching of the Law? Should pastors proclaim the Law in their sermons? Does the Law play a role in repentance? Yes. “The Law reveals the guilt of sin And makes us conscience-stricken; But then the Gospel enters in The sinful soul to quicken.”[5] As we remain in the fallen flesh we will have need for God’s holy Law, not as a means to make ourselves righteous but in order that we take hold of the depth of Christ’s saving work for us, delivered in the Gospel message of forgiveness." 其他的部份请再自行阅读连结全文。 -- 你们中间有人对他们说：「平平安安地去吧！愿你们穿得暖，吃得饱」， 却不给他们身体所需用的，这有甚麽益处呢？（雅2：16） --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc), 来自: 106.104.38.8 ※ 文章网址: https://webptt.com/cn.aspx?n=bbs/Christianity/M.1534789492.A.BA8.html ※ 编辑: theologe (106.104.38.8), 08/21/2018 02:34:48