评价不一 有几个有名的影评人据说都讨厌这部片 Oscarwatch的影迷，则是爱死了这部片 http://www.oscarwatch.com/forums/showthread.php?t=25447 FrankTJMackey： So, this was great. The Great German. It was pretty much everything I expected. As we could tell from the marketing, The Good German doesn't hide the fact that it's a throwback to epic 40s films like Casablanca, and the film makes no apologies for doing so. One thing I love about Soderbergh, in general, is his balls-out/experimental approach in some of his movies; already this year, we've seen something from him that no one else was doing, with Bubble. Now, with The Good German, he's given us something Talentedmrwelles： They really should rename it The FUCKING GREAT German. Steven Soderbergh has created a brilliant homage to the thrillers of the Golden Age of Hollywood. It evokes films from the 40s like The Maltese Falcon, Double Indemnity, The Third Man and A Foreign Affair, but it still feels fresh and never a copy of those classics. Soderbergh tightly directs Paul Anastasio's fantastic multi-layered script to perfection. 关於凯特 FrankTJMackey： And Blanchett. I've said already that she has the best collection of performances of the decade out of anyone else that has performed in film this decade, and The Good German is simply one more wonderful addition to an already brilliant list of performances. Lena is one of Blanchett's finest creations; her icy stare, her stature, her voice, all add to the mystery of Lena - yet Blanchett has a death grip on the character. Talentedmrwelles： Cate Blanchett commands the screen as Lena even when she is slinking in the shadows. She is an enigma with secrets upon secrets and Blanchett brilliantly controls what she chooses to reveal to the other characters and the audience alike. She makes Lena simultaneously frightening and sympathetic. 这部电影需要更多buzz 开出来的评论呈现两极 凯特的机会应该还不弱 但是不可能拿奖就是了 -- 【2006年】凯特布兰琪【全力大反攻】 ～丑闻笔记‧好德国人‧巴贝塔～ ～ＣＡＴＥ ＢＬＡＮＣＨＥＴＴ～ --

※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 61.224.40.57