作者JC1984 (Jeremy)
看板Britney
标题[心得] hold it against me? it's hard to say!
时间Tue Jan 11 10:52:24 2011
有监於妮粉一片好评,
贴一些广大美国人听完的综合评价吧....
请先吸一口气....
January 11, 2011 11:21a.m.
Don';t really like the song but from 2:20-3:20 I smell a sick dance routine
for the video ^_^
January 11, 2011 11:15a.m.
she is a best ... ever ... since .. Baby One More Time .. far Hold It Against
Me
January 11, 2011 11:13a.m.
this song is wack, melody is boring, almost monotone, i am not impressed at
all. is this a joke or something? but of course radio stations will eat it
up. i don';t get it. she has no vocal ability, never did. what is so great
about spears? hands? anyone?
January 11, 2011 9:58a.m.
Terrible. Terrible. And somehow it';ll probably get to number 1.
#KidsTheseDays
January 11, 2011 9:39a.m.
Just as I thought, absolute rubbish.
January 11, 2011 9:28a.m.
i dont really like this song, i think born this way will be mutch better!!!
January 11, 2011 8:56a.m.
I like the chorus, but not the lyrics and beat of the rest of the song.
Luckily, Britney has a lot more fans than Xtina, so I don';t think her
album/singles will flop like Xtina, but I dont predict a great chart run.
High debuts, few weeks strong, big drop
-------------------------以下是我个人心得-----------------------------
虽然没写过自介,
但当了紮紮实实10年的妮粉,
有谁像我连信箱、msn都是jerenybritneyXXXXXXXXXXDDDDDDDDD
但我在听了『HIAM』後,
还是觉得比较一般,
说不上特别的有『感动』,
而且非常直接的让我想到钱婆....
凭良心讲,
我个人觉得钱婆的声音听起来比较适合这种吵杂的歌,
因为她的声音有很强的穿透度,
所以感觉是在音乐之上的~
(虽然我不爱她的风格)
然而布兰妮一直以慵懒性感媚惑型的嗓音让人喜爱(slave之後)
突然又把声音『硬起来』
也许我个人还不是非常的适应吧~
最後,
我觉得比较可惜的部分,
这首歌对brit是一种创新没错,
但这跟blackout不一样,
它不音乐界的新标竿,
而是在一个已经红了的风格上再跨一步,
我对这首歌『接受』大於『满意』
但个人还是觉得这歌走在时下,应该会有好成绩啦!所以还是满开心的~
加油~brit~
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 122.116.127.102
1F:推 Mystic666:好险她有很多粉丝跟xtina,这句超贱lol 01/11 21:46
2F:推 seanleo0416:楼上..是她有比Xtina多很多粉丝 01/11 22:30
3F:推 wednesday323:我不是很喜欢这首歌,可是看大家一片好评 01/12 11:38
4F:→ wednesday323:让我都不敢发声 XD 01/12 11:38
5F:→ herohoney:这个版应该不会跟某些版一样吧 尽量讲阿 又不是不讲理XD 01/12 11:53
6F:→ forlornevan:嘎嘎呜啦啦~~~~~ 01/12 18:07