作者niufamily4 (来吃草吧)
看板BoardGame
标题[闲聊] 来自Rio Grande Games的回覆
时间Tue Feb 21 21:16:39 2012
前面关於侵权系列文闹得满城风雨
大家好像都忙着嘴炮忘了开心玩桌游!?
为此小弟以我破破的英文 写了一封信给多间美国的出版社
希望他们可以为广大的版众解惑一下
以下为我寄给他们的信件内容:
==============================
Dear Customer Service,
I am a board game fan from Taiwan, I like your games so much and hope you can
publish more fascinating games to us!
Recently, board game fans in Taiwan have come to some problems. Most of the
foreign board games are bought on official websites and shipping to Taiwan,
whether the retailers or players. Nothing big deal in purchasing goods
abroad. However, most of the games needs certain extents in reading English,
such as reading rule books or text on game cards, which is troublesome for
some of the board game fans in Taiwan.
Thus we make a solution: for rule books, we translate it into Chinese and
print it out; for game cards we translate it as well, printing it out in
small pieces and putting into card sleeves. It helps people who find
difficulty in reading English and make game proceeding smoothly.
We share the translating sheet to everyone who needed. Some retailer do the
same thing but charge as fee of translation. We are wondering if it's illegal
doing this kind of translation without permission from publisher and what if
sell to others for fee. Is it a violation of intellectual property rights?
What should we do to play the games with fun while not against the law?
Sorry for bothering you. We surely need your help to make things clear.
Hope can hear from you soon.
Sincerely,
XXX
==============================
今天收到了Rio Grande Games的回覆
请见下文:
==============================
I know some retailers offer the translations as part of the sale. If others
offer them for a small fee, we have no problem with this. Thanks
Jay
==============================
我打了两个小时的信 对方短短几句话就回答完了
老实说我还期待会看到"敝公司保留所有权利,请使用者慎行"之类的话 Orz
不过这算是好事吧
代表该公司其实允许商家翻译他们的规则书和卡表 翻译的蝇头小利也是OK的
(是不是"小利"不在本篇讨论范围中 请不要模糊焦点了 3Q ~ )
其他家出版商我还没收到回覆 届时再告诉大家吧 ~ ~
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.113.224.15
1F:推 fr014371:推! 02/21 21:18
2F:推 kingJ:有行动力有推 02/21 21:20
3F:推 nile520:推 02/21 21:20
4F:推 kaminari22tw:推!!请大家继续安心翻译各式各样的桌游吧XD 02/21 21:21
5F:推 laycelin:大推! 02/21 21:23
6F:推 recycling:推行动力!!! 02/21 21:23
7F:推 zzas:有心人,推一个! 02/21 21:24
8F:推 susuhd:推! 感动 02/21 21:25
9F:推 oktryit:看来这回答还蛮舒服的,感谢你提供的讯息 02/21 21:27
10F:推 waits:推~~~ 02/21 21:31
11F:推 b7736:也可看出外国人相对还是大气些! 有翻译可以让更多人接触 02/21 21:31
12F:→ b7736:有什麽不好得?还赚更多呢XD 02/21 21:32
13F:推 defiled:有行动有推 其实简单两句话也解决大家不少疑虑 02/21 21:32
14F:推 LiouKen:推一个 02/21 21:33
15F:推 issacm31:这就是答案!!推一个 02/21 21:37
16F:推 jk3: 推~有翻译有推广 02/21 21:41
17F:推 RXCPU:推你的行动力跟出版商的大气 让更多人可以推广 02/21 21:41
18F:推 whoami0404:舞照跳马照跑 佛心的佛心 赚钱的赚钱 酸民退散!!!! 02/21 21:46
19F:推 airfirewolf:推 实际行动求证~~ 02/21 21:53
20F:→ dadadiiii:平平是113 一篇受够了 一篇热心求证!! 02/21 21:55
21F:推 twinson:推 那争议可以落幕了吧 让有需要中文化的去买 又没强迫非 02/21 21:58
22F:→ twinson:买中文化不可 02/21 21:59
23F:推 Amoro:push~ 02/21 22:01
24F:推 ebv:推推~ 02/21 22:16
25F:推 Maxsel:push 02/21 22:20
26F:推 artyman:本来就是事先取得同意就ok BGG上面许多翻译都是如此 02/21 22:21
27F:→ artyman:反过来说 代理商进口产品 照说应该要附中文说明书 02/21 22:23
28F:推 guitarer:看来这吵闹的事件可以落幕了~~ 02/21 22:25
29F:推 aikobz:推一个 02/21 22:39
30F:推 obluda:谢谢热心 02/21 22:40
31F:→ aikobz:其实有人翻译帮忙推广 出版商应该也乐见其成吧 02/21 22:40
32F:推 aethe:推行动力 02/21 22:56
33F:推 minieyecheer:行动力十足阿!!推!!~~ 02/21 22:57
34F:推 colin90149:Mayfair: 02/21 22:59
35F:推 north4909:挖呜好威 02/21 23:00
36F:推 WADASHIWAKJ:其他游戏商也这样态度吗?只能说RIO不介意吧?? 02/21 23:25
37F:→ dephille:我觉得不用期待代理商给中文说明了...(?) 02/21 23:28
38F:推 one1016:推推推 02/21 23:31
39F:→ GGGGGforever:看某些人还有什麽东西可以嘴炮..... 02/21 23:37
40F:推 fiendfred:推!!考完又要开始买游戏了! 02/22 00:55
41F:推 smoox:恭喜楼上脱离苦海跳进深坑~ XD 02/22 01:17
42F:推 chidori728:推推!! 02/22 10:09
43F:推 kuiyy:还能说什麽~~~~推就对了XD 02/22 10:38
44F:→ dada80502:想询问一下他所说的要付一点费用,是要付给那个窗口呢? 02/22 12:13
45F:→ q90036:付给翻译的 02/22 12:30
46F:推 doden:值得推荐这篇文章 02/22 21:55
47F:推 shiunyuans:只能推这个行动派了 02/23 01:16
48F:推 RXCPU:依照文意来说 这一点费用是给提供翻译者的 他认为无伤大雅 02/24 06:57