看板Biology
标 题iNewland所引用的论文一堆错误--(4)
发信站不良牛牧场 (Sun Feb 10 21:06:54 2002)
转信站Ptt!news.ntu!bbs.ee.ntu!news.ee.ntu!SimFarm
现在来回答那些错的离谱的问题。
1.Why would antibodies against HIV (a positive HIV test), which
are so effective that leading AIDS researchers cannot detect
HIV in most AIDS patients (Gallo, 1991; Weiss, 1991; Cohen,
1993), not protect against AIDS?
答:很简单,因为retrovirus有一段provirus的时期,这时期你的
antibody一点用都没有,人类碰到HTLV-1时也是一样,抗体没有用。
3.Why are 9 out of 10 AIDS patients males?
答:数据错了,在非洲的男女罹病率是1:1,亚洲和南美接近5:4,
而欧美比较悬殊,但是绝对没有到九比一的地步。
(这种文章能登出来??)
4.Why are about two-thirds male homosexuals?
答:两个错误,首先是没有定义何谓「homosexual」,
再来比例也不对,依据Murray的微生物学课本,男性homosexual
& bisexual,还有一堆是异性恋者和血友病患呢。
6.Why are most AIDS patients 25-49 years old, and
why don't teenagers get AIDS?
答:回答这问题有损智商。不只teenager,
还有fetus是爱滋病患呢,无知。
8.Why would a new, sexually transmitted disease not have
exploded in the millions of heterosexually active Americans
and Europeans - just as syphilis once did in medieval Europe?
答:中世纪有静脉注射吗?中世纪会输血和器官移植吗?时代差这麽多,
还有,1996年为 止全球有27900000人罹病,早就不止millions了,
我能否再说你无知呢??
9.Why did HIV-positive American hemophiliacs live over twice as
long in 1987 as they did in the pre-AIDS era, and why has their
mortality increased ten-fold after the introduction of the
anti-HIV drug AZT?
答:自1960年才开使用血液治疗血友病者,1970年初因为肝炎随血液制剂
散播导致大规模死亡,1970年代末才控制住,接着出现HIV。这麽多的变因
在这,你所谓的the pre-AIDS era指的是哪一段啊?後一个问题因为没有
统计资料,我当你胡说八道。
--
我不是不喜欢这个人,
我根本是讨厌他!!!
--
Origin:<不良牛牧场> zoo.ee.ntu.edu.tw (140.112.18.36)
Welcome to SimFarm BBS -- From : [61-224-101-165.HINET-IP.hinet.net
]